Apple and Meta’s first DMA fines: appeals, compliance changes and a trade dispute
In April 2025 the European Commission fined Apple €500 million and Meta €200 million in its first decisions under the Digital Markets Act. Both companies are challenging the decisions in court while changing how they operate in the EU, and Washington has threatened trade retaliation over EU tech fines.

BRUSSELS On 23 April 2025 the European Commission found that Apple and Meta had broken the Digital Markets Act (DMA), the EU law that sets obligations for the largest digital platforms, which it calls gatekeepers. It fined Apple €500 million and Meta €200 million 1. The Commission said they were the first non-compliance decisions adopted under the DMA 1.
Both companies said they would appeal, and both have taken the Commission to the EU General Court 234. Both have also changed how they operate in the EU.
The two decisions
The Apple case concerned “steering”. Under the DMA, developers who distribute apps through the App Store should be able to tell customers, free of charge, about offers outside the store, direct them to those offers and let them buy there 1. The Commission found that Apple’s restrictions stopped developers from doing so, and that Apple had not shown they were objectively necessary and proportionate 1. It ordered Apple to remove the technical and commercial restrictions on steering and not to adopt conduct with an equivalent object or effect 1.
The Meta case concerned its “Consent or Pay” model, introduced in November 2023. EU users of Facebook and Instagram could either consent to the combination of their personal data for personalised advertising or pay a monthly subscription for an ad-free service 1. The Commission found that this did not give users a less personalised but otherwise equivalent option, and did not let them freely consent to their data being combined, as Article 5(2) of the DMA requires 13. The finding covers March 2024, when the obligations became binding, to November 2024, when Meta introduced a new version of its free ads model 1.
The Commission said both companies had to comply within 60 days or risk periodic penalty payments 1. Under the DMA it can fine companies up to 10% of their global annual turnover 1.
“Apple and Meta have fallen short of compliance with the DMA by implementing measures that reinforce the dependence of business users and consumers on their platforms,” said Teresa Ribera, an Executive Vice-President of the Commission 1.
Responses and the US reaction
Apple said in a statement: “Despite countless meetings, the Commission continues to move the goal posts every step of the way. We will appeal and continue engaging with the Commission in service of our European customers” 4. Joel Kaplan, Meta’s chief global affairs officer, said: “The European Commission is attempting to handicap successful American businesses while allowing Chinese and European companies to operate under different standards” 4.
The White House also objected. “This novel form of economic extortion will not be tolerated by the United States,” a spokesperson said 5.
The court challenges
Meta filed its action at the General Court on 4 July 2025 (Case T-435/25) 3. It asks the court to annul the decision or annul or reduce the fine 3. Its arguments include that the Commission misread a 2023 judgment of the EU Court of Justice, Case C-252/21, and breached Meta’s rights of defence 3. “This decision is both incorrect and unlawful, and we are appealing it,” wrote Tim Lamb, a Meta legal vice-president 6.
Apple filed its action on 7 July 2025 (Case T-438/25) 2. It relies on five pleas, including that the Commission misinterpreted Article 5(4) and had no legal basis to impose a fine 2. “Today we filed our appeal because we believe the European Commission’s decision – and their unprecedented fine – go far beyond what the law requires,” Apple said 7. The Commission responded: “We stand ready to defend our decisions in court” 7.
Apple is also challenging other DMA decisions. In March 2025 the Commission ordered it to open certain iPhone features to connected devices such as smartwatches and headphones 8. Apple challenged one of those decisions on 30 May 2025 and asked the court to declare the DMA’s interoperability article inapplicable (Case T-354/25) 9. AFP reported in August 2026 that a separate Apple challenge, arguing that stricter DMA rules should not apply to iOS and the App Store, had been thrown out by an EU court the previous month 10.
How it unfolded
-
Commission opens DMA investigations into Apple’s steering rules and Meta’s ‘pay or consent’ model.
-
Key moment. Apple fined €500 million and Meta €200 million in the first DMA non-compliance decisions.
-
Apple changes its EU App Store rules and fees as the compliance deadline arrives.
-
Meta files its action at the EU General Court (T-435/25).
-
Apple files its action at the General Court (T-438/25).
-
Commission says Meta will offer a less personalised ads choice from January 2026.
-
Key moment. Google fined €890 million under the DMA.
-
Trump announces a Section 301 investigation over EU fines.
-
Apple announces new EU terms; the Commission welcomes them.
-
Google appeals both DMA decisions.
Changes to comply
Apple changed its EU App Store rules and fees on 26 June 2025. It said it disagreed with the outcome and planned to appeal 11. The Commission said it wanted the views of market operators and other interested parties before deciding on next steps 11.
On 8 December 2025 the Commission said Meta had undertaken to give EU users a choice between sharing all their data for fully personalised advertising and sharing less data for more limited personalised advertising, starting in January 2026 12. “Users in the EU must have full and effective choice, which is their right under the DMA,” the Commission said 12. Reuters reported that Meta would not face daily fines 13. In October 2026 Meta said it had made significant changes to its less personalised ads offering since the decision, and that more changes could be imposed while its appeal is under way 14.
On 18 August 2026 Apple announced new EU business terms, which took effect on 1 October 2026 15. They replace its per-install Core Technology Fee with a 5% Core Technology Commission and cut the commission on in-app purchases to 26% 15. “These changes resolve Apple’s disagreements with the Commission over business terms and alternative distribution,” Apple said 15. The Commission said it welcomed the changes 1015. “At this stage the Commission is not considering periodic penalty payments, but is rather monitoring the announced measure,” a spokesperson said 10.
Google and Section 301
On 23 July 2026 the Commission fined Google €460 million for favouring its own services in Google Search and €430 million for restricting steering on Google Play, a total of €890 million 16. “The best products should succeed because they’re better, not because they’re owned by the company running the search engine,” Ribera said 16. Alphabet, Google’s parent company, says it appealed both decisions in October 2026 17.
The Commission is also using the DMA in other ways. In November 2025 it opened an investigation into whether Google demotes news publishers’ content in search results 18. In July 2026 it issued binding measures requiring Google to give rival AI assistants access to Android features and to share search data with other search engines 1920.
On 24 July 2026, the day after the Google fine, President Donald Trump said on Truth Social that the US would start a Section 301 trade investigation into EU fines on American companies 2122. “The European Union will pay a very big price for this illegal and highly unethical conduct,” he wrote 22. In an August 2025 joint statement on trade, the US and the EU had committed to address “unjustified digital trade barriers” 23.
Latest status
As of 18 November 2026, Apple’s and Meta’s actions against the April 2025 decisions are still pending, according to their latest filings 1424. Apple says it believes it complies with the DMA 24. Its annual report also lists a separate investigation into its terms for alternative app distribution, in which the Commission issued preliminary findings in April 2025 24. Google’s appeals are also pending 17.
Why it matters
The April 2025 decisions were the first time the Commission fined companies under the DMA 1. Since then both Apple and Meta have changed their EU business models under the threat of further penalties, while still contesting the original findings in court 142410. Washington’s response to the Google fine shows that EU enforcement is now also a trade issue 2122.
Sources and references
- Official documentEuropean Commission, “Commission finds Apple and Meta in breach of the Digital Markets Act (IP/25/1085)”, 23 April 2025. Link
- Court documentOfficial Journal of the EU / General Court, “Action brought on 7 July 2025 – Apple v Commission (Case T-438/25), OJ C/2025/5215”, 6 October 2025. Link
- Court documentOfficial Journal of the EU / General Court, “Action brought on 4 July 2025 – Meta Platforms v Commission (Case T-435/25), OJ C/2025/5214”, 6 October 2025. Link
- ArticleITPro, “Apple, Meta hit back at EU after landmark DMA fines”, 24 April 2025. Link
- ArticleThe Star / Reuters, “US calls EU fines on Apple and Meta ‘economic extortion’ (Reuters)”, 24 April 2025. Link
- Official documentMeta, “Why the Commission’s Decision Undermines the Goals of the DMA (Tim Lamb)”, 2 July 2025. Link
- ArticleITPro, “’Confusing for developers and bad for users’: Apple launches appeal over ‘unprecedented’ EU fine”, 8 July 2025. Link
- Official documentEuropean Commission, “Commission provides guidance under Digital Markets Act to facilitate development of innovative products on Apple’s platforms (IP/25/816)”, 19 March 2025. Link
- Court documentOfficial Journal of the EU / General Court, “Action brought on 30 May 2025 – Apple and Apple Distribution International v Commission (Case T-354/25)”. Link
- ArticleThe Star / AFP, “EU ‘welcomes’ Apple steps to comply with digital rules (AFP)”, 19 August 2026. Link
- ArticleThe Star / Reuters, “Apple changes App Store rules in EU to comply with antitrust order (Reuters)”, 27 June 2025. Link
- Official documentEuropean Commission (DMA website), “Meta commits to give EU users choice on personalised ads under Digital Markets Act”, 8 December 2025. Link
- ArticleThe Star / Reuters, “Meta pledge to use less personal data for ads gets EU nod, avoids daily fines (Reuters)”, 8 December 2025. Link
- Official documentMeta Platforms / US SEC, “Meta Platforms Form 10-Q for the quarter ended 30 September 2026”, 22 October 2026. Link
- ArticleThe Next Web, “Apple EU App Store fees / Core Technology Commission”, 18 August 2026. Link
- Official documentEuropean Commission, “Commission fines Google €890 million for breaches of the Digital Markets Act (IP/26/1670)”, 23 July 2026. Link
- Official documentAlphabet Inc. / US SEC, “Alphabet Inc. Form 10-Q for the quarter ended 30 September 2026”, 29 October 2026. Link
- Official documentEuropean Commission (DMA website), “Commission opens investigation into potential DMA breach by Google in demoting media publishers’ content”, 13 November 2025. Link
- Official documentEuropean Commission (DMA website), “Commission opens proceedings to assist Google in complying with interoperability and online search data sharing obligations”, 27 January 2026. Link
- Official documentEuropean Commission (DMA website), “Commission provides guidance to Google for AI interoperability on Android and sharing of Google Search data”, 16 July 2026. Link
- ArticleEngadget, “Trump threatens EU with new tariffs in response to Google fine”, 24 July 2026. Link
- ArticleThe National News Desk (Sinclair), “Trump targets EU over Google fine, putting trade deal at risk”, 27 July 2026. Link
- Official documentEuropean Commission (DG Trade), “Joint Statement on a United States-European Union framework on an agreement on reciprocal, fair and balanced trade”, 21 August 2025. Link
- Official documentApple Inc. / US SEC, “Apple Inc. Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended 26 September 2026”. Link
Sources and references are provided for transparency and further reading. Allegations and claims are attributed to their respective sources. Triple Frontiers distinguishes reported allegations from independently established facts.
The Frontier Brief
The week’s essential international reporting and new investigations, every Friday.



