Triple Frontiers
Explainer

Apple’s App Store in the US courts: contempt, a criminal referral and a Supreme Court fight

A US judge found in April 2025 that Apple wilfully defied an order to open the App Store to outside payment links, and referred it for a possible criminal contempt investigation. An appeals court upheld the finding but let Apple seek a fee. The Supreme Court will now hear the case, as a separate Justice Department lawsuit grinds through discovery.

Aerial view of the ring-shaped Apple Park headquarters building at sunset
Apple Park, Apple's headquarters in Cupertino, California (file photo, 2024).Photo: Nils Huenerfuerst / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

On 30 April 2025 Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers of the US District Court for the Northern District of California found Apple in “willful violation” of an injunction she had issued in Epic Games’ lawsuit over the App Store 1. She barred Apple from charging any commission on purchases that users make outside an app, and referred Apple and its Vice-President of Finance, Alex Roman, to federal prosecutors to investigate whether criminal contempt proceedings are appropriate 12.

The Supreme Court will hear Apple’s challenge to the contempt finding on 11 January 2027, while the Oakland court decides what fee Apple may charge on those purchases 34. A separate Justice Department monopolisation case is in discovery in New Jersey 5.

The injunction and Apple’s response

In September 2021, after a trial, Judge Gonzalez Rogers rejected Epic’s federal antitrust claims but ruled that some of Apple’s anti-steering rules broke California’s Unfair Competition Law 16. Her injunction barred Apple from prohibiting developers from including buttons, external links or other calls to action that direct customers to purchasing mechanisms other than Apple’s In-App Purchase system 6.

The Ninth Circuit affirmed in relevant part in April 2023, and the injunction took effect after the Supreme Court declined review on 16 January 2024 1. That day Apple filed a compliance plan allowing links but charging a commission of 12% to 27% on linked purchases made within seven days of a user clicking out of an app 6.

The contempt ruling and criminal referral

The judge found that Apple had charged a 27% commission on off-app purchases and added barriers such as full-page “scare” screens to maintain its “anticompetitive revenue stream” 1. She wrote that Alex Roman “outright lied under oath”, and that Tim Cook had ignored Phillip Schiller’s advice to comply and let Chief Financial Officer Luca Maestri and his finance team persuade him otherwise 1.

“This is an injunction, not a negotiation. There are no do-overs once a party willfully disregards a court order,” she wrote 1. The order, effective immediately, also barred Apple from restricting the style, language, formatting or placement of developers’ links and buttons 16.

The referral to the US Attorney for the Northern District of California is a request to investigate, not a charge 1. The judge wrote: “The Court takes no position on whether a criminal prosecution is or is not warranted.” 1

Apple said it strongly disagreed with the decision 2. “We will comply with the court’s order and we will appeal,” it said in a statement reported by Reuters 2. Epic’s chief executive, Tim Sweeney, said: “It forces Apple to compete with other payment services rather than blocking them, and this is what we wanted all along.” 2 Fortnite, removed in 2020, returned to the US App Store on 20 May 2025 7.

The Ninth Circuit appeal

“We affirm the district court’s contempt findings,” a Ninth Circuit panel wrote on 11 December 2025 8. The panel held that the 27% commission had a prohibitive effect and that Apple’s restrictions on link design violated the injunction 8.

But the panel reversed the total ban on commissions, saying that as written it was “more like a punitive criminal contempt sanction” than a civil one 8. It sent the issue back for the district court to recast the ban as a purgeable civil contempt sanction or as a properly tailored modification of the injunction 8.

The panel suggested a commission based on costs “genuinely and reasonably necessary” for coordinating external links, with nothing for security and privacy features, and no commission at all until the district court approves a fee 8.

How it unfolded

  1. Judgment for Epic on California unfair-competition claim; anti-steering injunction issued.

  2. Supreme Court declines review; Apple announces commission of up to 27% on link-out purchases.

  3. Justice Department and states sue Apple in New Jersey.

  4. Key moment. Apple held in wilful violation; criminal contempt referral to US Attorney.

  5. Fortnite returns to the US App Store.

  6. Judge Neals denies Apple’s motion to dismiss DOJ case.

  7. Key moment. Ninth Circuit upholds contempt but reverses total commission ban.

  8. Mandate issues; Justice Kagan denies stay.

  9. Key moment. Supreme Court agrees to review the contempt standard.

  10. Apple proposes link-out commissions of 5% to 15%.

  11. DOJ case fact discovery extended to May 2027.

  12. Epic alleges Apple is withholding over 122,000 documents.

  13. Key moment. Supreme Court argument scheduled.

The commission fight

The Ninth Circuit denied rehearing on 30 March 2026 and issued its mandate on 6 May, the same day Justice Elena Kagan refused Apple’s request to put it on hold 3910. On 30 June the Supreme Court agreed to hear Apple’s appeal, limited to one question: whether a court may hold a party in civil contempt for violating an injunction’s “spirit” where the injunction is silent on the conduct in question 311.

On 11 August 2026 the judge refused Apple’s request to pause the remand, writing that the fact-finding ordered by the Ninth Circuit would be needed whatever the Supreme Court decides, and that “Given Apple’s propensity to delay, this phase will likely take time.” 4 Justice Kagan denied a further stay request on 13 August 3.

The same day Apple proposed US link-out commissions of 15% for standard apps, 10% for apps in its video, news and mini-apps partner programmes and for subscription renewals, and 5% for apps in its Small Business Program 12. Apple argued that the costs defined by the Ninth Circuit were so small that they would support a commission of “essentially zero”, and that tying its fee to those costs would be inconsistent with the law 12. Its expert reported that US in-app purchase billings fell relative to international levels between March and June 2026 under the current “zero-commission” regime 12.

On 13 November Epic alleged that Apple was withholding more than 122,000 documents about how it chose its proposed fee, on the ground that they were not relevant 13. “Apple is back at it,” the motion said, asking for a daily fine if Apple has not produced them by 2 December 13. The judge referred the dispute to Magistrate Judge Thomas S. Hixson on 17 November 14.

Apple’s case in the Supreme Court

Apple’s brief of 14 September 2026 argues that the injunction did not address commissions and that contempt requires an order that leaves no fair ground of doubt about what is forbidden 6. It says Apple “would never intentionally disregard a court order” and asks the justices to reverse the contempt ruling and vacate the remand instructions 6. The United States filed a brief supporting neither party 3.

The Justice Department’s case

On 21 March 2024 the Justice Department and state attorneys general sued Apple in federal court in New Jersey, alleging that it illegally maintains a smartphone monopoly by restricting super apps, cloud-streaming services, cross-platform messaging, third-party smartwatches and digital wallets 1516. Apple said: “We believe this lawsuit is wrong on the facts and the law, and we will vigorously defend against it.” 15

On 30 June 2025 Judge Julien Xavier Neals denied Apple’s motion to dismiss the amended complaint, brought by the United States, 19 states and the District of Columbia 1718. The complaint alleges that Apple holds 65% of the US smartphone market, an allegation not yet tested at trial 17.

In September 2026 a special master paused his order requiring the government to produce documents from 14 federal agencies, pending an appeal, noting that the case was “very much in the earlier phases of discovery” 1920. An amended scheduling order of 6 November 2026 extended fact discovery to 28 May 2027 and expert discovery to 5 November 2027; it does not set a trial date 5.

Where things stand

As of 18 November 2026, the contempt finding stands, subject to the Supreme Court’s review, with argument set for 11 January 2027 3. The Ninth Circuit left it to the district court to decide what commission, if any, Apple may charge on US link-out purchases, and on 17 November Epic’s discovery motion was referred to Magistrate Judge Hixson 81314. Whether to pursue criminal contempt remains a matter for the US Attorney 1.

Why it matters

The contempt ruling opened the US App Store to commission-free links to outside payment, and Apple’s own expert reports that US in-app billings have fallen relative to other countries since 112. The Supreme Court’s question, whether contempt can rest on an injunction’s “spirit”, applies to any party bound by a court order 11. If the justices side with Apple, the company argues, the remand on its commission falls away with the contempt finding 6. The Justice Department’s broader case remains in discovery, which under the current schedule runs to November 2027 5.

Sources and references

  1. Court documentUS District Court for the Northern District of California (via CourtListener), “Epic Games v. Apple, Order granting Epic’s motion to enforce injunction; referral to US Attorney re criminal contempt, Dkt. 1508”, 30 April 2025. Link
  2. ArticleNBC News / Reuters, “U.S. judge rules Apple violated order to reform App Store (Reuters)”, 1 May 2025. Link
  3. Court documentSupreme Court of the United States, “Docket No. 25-1311, Apple Inc. v. Epic Games, Inc.”, 27 May 2026. Link
  4. Court documentUS District Court for the Northern District of California (via CourtListener), “Order denying Apple’s motion to stay proceedings (Dkt. 1706)”, 11 August 2026. Link
  5. Court documentUS District Court for the District of New Jersey (via CourtListener), “Amended Scheduling Order (ECF 596)”, 6 November 2026. Link
  6. Court documentApple Inc. (filed in the Supreme Court of the United States), “Brief for Petitioner Apple Inc., No. 25-1311”, 14 September 2026. Link
  7. ArticleArab News / Associated Press, “Fortnite video game returns to iPhone app store in US, ending exile imposed by Apple (AP)”, 21 May 2025. Link
  8. Court documentUS Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, “Epic Games, Inc. v. Apple Inc., No. 25-2935, Opinion”, 11 December 2025. Link
  9. Court documentSupreme Court of the United States, “Docket No. 25A1213, Apple Inc. v. Epic Games, Inc. (application for stay)”, 6 May 2026. Link
  10. Court documentUS Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (via CourtListener), “Ninth Circuit mandate, No. 25-2935 (Dkt. 1677)”, 6 May 2026. Link
  11. Court documentSupreme Court of the United States, “No. 25-1311 Questions Presented (cert. granted 6/30/2026, limited to Question 1)”, 30 June 2026. Link
  12. Court documentApple Inc. (filed in N.D. Cal., via CourtListener), “Defendant Apple Inc.’s Remand Proffer, redacted (Dkt. 1708)”, 13 August 2026. Link
  13. Court documentEpic Games, Inc. (filed in N.D. Cal., via CourtListener), “Epic Games’ Motion to Enforce Order re Production (Dkt. 1727)”, 13 November 2026. Link
  14. Court documentUS District Court for the Northern District of California (via CourtListener), “Order of referral to Magistrate Judge Thomas S. Hixson (Dkt. 1728)”, 17 November 2026. Link
  15. ArticleMacRumors, “Apple Sued by U.S. Department of Justice, Says Lawsuit is ‘Wrong’”, 21 March 2024. Link
  16. Official documentNational Association of Attorneys General, “U.S. and Plaintiff States v. Apple, Inc., No. 2:24-cv-04055 (D.N.J. Mar. 21, 2024)”. Link
  17. Court documentUS District Court for the District of New Jersey (via NAAG), “United States v. Apple Inc., No. 24-cv-4055, Opinion denying motion to dismiss (ECF 283)”, 30 June 2025. Link
  18. ArticleThe Star / Reuters, “Apple loses bid to dismiss US smartphone monopoly case (Reuters)”, 1 July 2025. Link
  19. Court documentUS District Court for the District of New Jersey (via CourtListener), “Order of the Special Discovery Master re stay of July 14, 2026 order (ECF 515)”, 10 September 2026. Link
  20. Article9to5Mac, “DOJ wins pause on order requiring documents from 14 agencies in Apple antitrust case”, 10 September 2026. Link

Sources and references are provided for transparency and further reading. Allegations and claims are attributed to their respective sources. Triple Frontiers distinguishes reported allegations from independently established facts.

Spotted an error? Request a correction · Corrections policy

Share this story

Apple’s App Store in the US courts: contempt, a criminal referral and a Supreme Court fight

Newsroom desk Technology Desk

Technology, security and the digital economy. Stories are researched from official records, court documents, institutional reports and published journalism, with the help of AI research tools, and edited for Triple Frontiers. Every factual claim is linked to its source.

Newsletter

The Frontier Brief

The week’s essential international reporting and new investigations, every Friday.