WhatsApp v NSO: the Pegasus verdict, the cut damages and the unpaid judgment
A US jury ordered NSO Group to pay more than $167 million for hacking WhatsApp users with Pegasus. A judge cut that to $4.4 million and banned NSO from targeting WhatsApp. NSO, now under US ownership, is appealing, and WhatsApp says it has not been paid.

OAKLAND On 6 May 2025 a federal jury in California ordered Israeli spyware maker NSO Group to pay WhatsApp and its parent Meta $444,719 in compensatory damages and $167,254,000 in punitive damages over the hacking of WhatsApp users with Pegasus spyware 12. The judge later cut the punitive award to $4,002,471 and permanently barred NSO from targeting WhatsApp 34.
As of 18 November 2026, NSO’s appeal to the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit is fully briefed and has not been decided 5. WhatsApp says NSO owes it more than $20 million and has paid nothing 6.
The 2019 attack and the liability ruling
WhatsApp sued NSO and its parent, Q Cyber Technologies, on 29 October 2019, alleging that they sent malware through WhatsApp’s system to approximately 1,400 mobile phones and devices to surveil their users 7. The claims were under the federal Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, a California computer crime law and for breach of contract 7. NSO’s immunity defences were finally rejected on 9 January 2023, and the case returned to the trial court 6.
On 20 December 2024 Judge Phyllis J. Hamilton of the US District Court for the Northern District of California granted WhatsApp summary judgment on all three claims, leaving damages to be decided at trial 78. She found that NSO had “repeatedly failed to produce relevant discovery and failed to obey court orders regarding such discovery”, notably the Pegasus source code, and imposed evidentiary sanctions 7.
“Surveillance companies should be on notice that illegal spying will not be tolerated,” Will Cathcart, the head of WhatsApp, wrote on social media 8. NSO did not immediately comment; it had previously denied wrongdoing and said its products are used to fight crime and terrorism 8.
The jury verdict
The jury’s unanimous verdict totalled $167,698,719 1. The jury awarded the full $444,719 in compensatory damages WhatsApp had sought and found that NSO acted with malice, oppression or fraud 3.
Meta called the verdict “an important step forward for privacy and security as the first victory against the development and use of illegal spyware that threatens the safety and privacy of everyone” 92. NSO said it would “carefully examine the verdict’s details and pursue appropriate legal remedies, including further proceedings and an appeal” 2.
The reduction and the injunction
On 17 October 2025 Judge Hamilton granted NSO’s motion to reduce the punitive damages to $4,002,471, nine times the compensatory award 310. She found no sufficient basis to call NSO’s conduct “particularly egregious”, the category that could justify a higher ratio, writing that “there have simply not yet been enough cases involving unlawful electronic surveillance in the smartphone era” to reach that conclusion 3.
In the same order she granted WhatsApp a permanent injunction, rejecting NSO’s argument that it “would put NSO’s entire enterprise at risk” and “force NSO out of business” 3. She ruled that it could not apply to NSO’s foreign government customers, who were not parties to the case 34. WhatsApp accepted the reduced award, and on 12 November 2025 the court entered the injunction and a final judgment of $4,447,190 1.
The injunction bars NSO from developing, using or selling any technology that interacts with or emulates any aspect of the WhatsApp platform without permission, and from creating WhatsApp accounts 411. It also requires NSO to delete code that depends on WhatsApp and to disable customer access to such technology 11. On 30 January 2026 the court added $15,914,095 in attorney’s fees 12.
“Today’s ruling bans spyware maker NSO from ever targeting WhatsApp and our global users again,” Mr Cathcart said 10. NSO spokesperson Gil Lainer said: “While the remaining sum is still disproportionately high, this significant reduction marks a step in the right direction.” 10 He welcomed the exclusion of NSO’s customers from the injunction 10.
How it unfolded
-
WhatsApp and Meta sue NSO Group over attacks on about 1,400 devices.
-
Key moment. Judge Hamilton finds NSO liable; trial limited to damages.
-
Key moment. Jury awards $444,719 compensatory and $167,254,000 punitive damages.
-
NSO confirms US investors have taken controlling ownership.
-
Key moment. Punitive damages cut to $4,002,471; permanent injunction granted.
-
Final judgment of $4,447,190 and injunction entered.
-
Key moment. NSO appeals to the Ninth Circuit.
-
Court awards $15,914,095 in attorney’s fees.
-
WhatsApp seeks to hold NSO in contempt.
-
Appeal briefing completed.
-
Key moment. Contempt motion denied.
-
Final briefs filed in dispute over NSO’s assets.
New owners
On 10 October 2025 NSO confirmed that “an American investment group has invested tens of millions of dollars in the company and has acquired controlling ownership” 13. Israeli outlet Calcalist reported that the group was led by Hollywood producer Robert Simonds 13. NSO said its headquarters and core operations remain in Israel 13.
In November 2025 NSO named David Friedman, US ambassador to Israel in Donald Trump’s first administration, as executive chairman, and said its three founders no longer held any stake 14. Mr Friedman told the Wall Street Journal that the WhatsApp ruling was a “meaningful setback” 14. Chief executive Yaron Shohat stepped down and co-founder Omri Lavie left 15.
The appeal
NSO filed its notice of appeal on 19 November 2025, and both the trial court and the Ninth Circuit refused to suspend the injunction while the appeal proceeds, according to NSO’s appeal brief 16. “The consequences of affirming would be catastrophic,” its brief says, arguing that law enforcement and intelligence agencies would lose tools used against terrorists and child predators 16. It asks the court to reverse liability, vacate or narrow the injunction and, at a minimum, cut punitive damages; it proposes a 4:1 ratio, or about $1,778,876 16.
WhatsApp’s brief of 13 May 2026 asks for the judgment to be upheld in full 17. “The question before this Court is not whether surveillance technology can serve a legitimate purpose in the abstract,” it says, but whether NSO broke the law in deploying this spyware system 17. Amicus briefs were filed in May 2026 by the Knight First Amendment Institute and by groups including Access Now and the Committee to Protect Journalists, and NSO filed its reply on 1 July 2026 5. The latest docket entry, on 24 August 2026, is WhatsApp’s response to an NSO letter citing new case law 5.
A failed contempt bid and an unpaid judgment
On 8 June 2026 WhatsApp asked the court to hold NSO in contempt, alleging that it had created at least 23 new WhatsApp accounts and that malicious links had been sent to targets over WhatsApp in February and April 2026 1811. NSO said the evidence was “a far cry from ‘clear and convincing evidence'” and argued that a foreign government’s own decision to send a link would not breach the injunction 19.
On 16 October 2026 Judge Hamilton denied the motion 11. “In the court’s view, plaintiffs took a calculated risk in choosing to limit the level of detail in their supporting evidence,” she wrote 11. She declined to rule that customers’ use of such links always falls outside the injunction, saying that depended on NSO’s role 11.
The fight has moved to collection. WhatsApp says NSO owes $20,361,285 excluding interest and “has paid nothing, posted no bond, and sought no stay” 6. NSO argues that WhatsApp seeks an “unjustified and disproportional examination” of the worldwide assets of companies that are not judgment debtors 20. Both sides filed their final briefs on 13 November 2026, and the judge will decide the dispute on the papers 2122.
Other spyware cases
A suit by journalists from El Salvador’s El Faro against NSO was revived by the Ninth Circuit on 8 July 2025, but on 30 September 2026 Judge James Donato dismissed it for lack of personal jurisdiction 2324. “The court’s decision is disappointing, but we intend to appeal,” said Carrie DeCell of the Knight First Amendment Institute 25.
In Greece, an Athens court on 26 February 2026 convicted Intellexa founder Tal Dilian and three others at first instance over the Predator spyware scandal, with eight years of each sentence to be served and the rest suspended pending appeal 26. The defendants had denied involvement 27.
Why it matters
The WhatsApp case produced a jury verdict and a permanent injunction against a spyware vendor that sells to governments 1416. Its limits are as clear: punitive damages were cut by more than 97 per cent, the injunction excludes NSO’s customers, and the contempt bid failed 17311. Whether WhatsApp’s victory holds now depends on the Ninth Circuit, and on whether it can collect 56.
Sources and references
- Court documentU.S. District Court, N.D. California (via CourtListener), “Final Judgment (Dkt. 810)”, 12 November 2025. Link
- ArticleNBC News (Reuters), “Meta wins $168 million verdict against spyware company NSO”, 6 May 2025. Link
- Court documentU.S. District Court, N.D. California (via CourtListener), “Order re Motion for Permanent Injunction, Motion for Remittitur or New Trial, and Motion to Seal (Dkt. 802)”, 17 October 2025. Link
- Court documentU.S. District Court, N.D. California (via CourtListener), “Order Granting Plaintiffs’ Motion for Permanent Injunction (Dkt. 809)”, 12 November 2025. Link
- Court documentCourtListener, “WhatsApp v. NSO Group Technologies Limited, 9th Cir. No. 25-7380, docket feed (entries 20-49)”, 24 August 2026. Link
- Court documentWhatsApp and Meta / N.D. California (via CourtListener), “Plaintiffs’ Motion to Compel Post-Judgment Discovery (Dkt. 888)”, 30 October 2026. Link
- Court documentU.S. District Court, N.D. California (via CourtListener), “WhatsApp Inc. v. NSO Group Technologies Ltd., Order re Motions for Summary Judgment, Motion for Sanctions, and Discovery Letter Briefs (Dkt. 494)”, 20 December 2024. Link
- ArticleCNN, “Judge rules Israeli firm NSO Group liable for damages in WhatsApp hacking case”, 20 December 2024. Link
- Official documentMeta, “Winning the Fight Against Spyware Merchant NSO”, 6 May 2025. Link
- ArticleCyberScoop, “WhatsApp wins injunction against NSO Group; damages reduced”, 20 October 2025. Link
- Court documentU.S. District Court, N.D. California (via CourtListener), “Order Denying Motion for Contempt (Dkt. 884)”, 16 October 2026. Link
- Court documentU.S. District Court, N.D. California (via CourtListener), “Order Granting Motion for Attorney’s Fees, Denying Motion to Seal (Dkt. 835)”, 30 January 2026. Link
- ArticleTechCrunch, “Spyware maker NSO Group confirms acquisition by US investors”, 10 October 2025. Link
- ArticleThe Record (Recorded Future News), “Former Trump official named NSO Group executive chairman”, 10 November 2025. Link
- ArticleTechCrunch, “Critics pan spyware maker NSO’s transparency claims amid its push to enter US market”, 8 January 2026. Link
- Court documentNSO Group / U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (via CourtListener), “Defendants-Appellants’ Opening Brief, No. 25-7380”, 11 February 2026. Link
- Court documentWhatsApp and Meta / U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (via CourtListener), “Plaintiffs-Appellees’ Answering Brief, No. 25-7380”, 13 May 2026. Link
- Court documentWhatsApp and Meta / N.D. California (via CourtListener), “Plaintiffs’ Notice of Motion and Motion for Contempt (Dkt. 854)”, 8 June 2026. Link
- Court documentNSO Group / N.D. California (via CourtListener), “Defendants’ Opposition to Motion for Contempt (Dkt. 863)”, 22 June 2026. Link
- Court documentNSO Group / N.D. California (via CourtListener), “Defendants’ Motion for Entry of Protective Order (Dkt. 886)”, 30 October 2026. Link
- Court documentCourtListener, “WhatsApp Inc. v. NSO Group Technologies Limited, 4:19-cv-07123, docket feed (entries 869-894)”, 13 November 2026. Link
- Court documentU.S. District Court, N.D. California (via CourtListener), “Order re Post-Judgment Discovery Disputes (Dkt. 885)”, 16 October 2026. Link
- Court documentU.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, “Dada v. NSO Group, Memorandum, Nos. 24-2179, 24-3463”, 8 July 2025. Link
- Court documentU.S. District Court, N.D. California (hosted by Knight Institute), “Dada v. NSO Group, Order re Renewed Motion to Dismiss (Dkt. 107), No. 3:22-cv-07513-JD”, 30 September 2026. Link
- Official documentKnight First Amendment Institute, “Court Dismisses Journalists’ Case Against Spyware Manufacturer NSO Group”, 30 September 2026. Link
- ArticleTo Vima, “Guilty Verdict in Greece’s Predator Spyware Trial”, 26 February 2026. Link
- ArticleArab News (AFP), “Greek court to deliver verdict on 2022 spyware scandal”, 26 February 2026. Link
Sources and references are provided for transparency and further reading. Allegations and claims are attributed to their respective sources. Triple Frontiers distinguishes reported allegations from independently established facts.
The Frontier Brief
The week’s essential international reporting and new investigations, every Friday.



