Triple Frontiers
Retrospective · Cybersecurity

Paragon spyware in Italy: who hacked the journalists and activists?

In January 2025 WhatsApp warned about 90 users that Paragon's Graphite spyware had targeted them, including an Italian editor and migrant-rescue activists. Italy admitted its intelligence agencies used the tool on the activists but denied targeting journalists. Prosecutors later confirmed the editor's phone was hacked, and are still looking for whoever did it.

RetrospectiveEvents of 31 January 2025. Published by Triple Frontiers on 18 November 2026 as part of our archive covering events before our launch, based on the sources listed below.
Cream-coloured facade of Palazzo Chigi with Italian and EU flags above the entrance, on an open square
Palazzo Chigi in Rome, seat of the Italian prime minister's office, which denied in February 2025 that intelligence services had monitored journalists (file photo, 2023).Photo: DellaGherardesca / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

On 31 January 2025 WhatsApp said it had disrupted a spyware campaign that it attributed to Paragon Solutions, a company that sells a phone-hacking tool called Graphite 1. About 90 users in more than two dozen countries were targeted, including journalists and members of civil society, and WhatsApp said it believed the attacks took place in December 2024 12. One of those notified was Francesco Cancellato, editor-in-chief of the Italian news site Fanpage.it 3.

Almost two years later, the affair has produced an admission that Italian intelligence agencies used Graphite against migrant-rescue activists, a parliamentary finding that they did not target Cancellato, and a prosecutors’ report confirming that his phone was nonetheless compromised 45. Prosecutors are investigating persons unknown over the hacking of the journalist 657.

Notifications and denials

Paragon was founded in Israel in 2019, and its founders include the former Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak 2. It was acquired in December 2024 by the US private equity firm AE Industrial Partners 1. WhatsApp said the attack required no action from the target and relied on malicious PDF files sent through WhatsApp groups; it said it had fixed the flaw and sent Paragon a cease-and-desist letter 1.

“I feel violated,” Cancellato told TechCrunch, adding that he and Fanpage had contacted the authorities 3. On 5 February the office of Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said it ruled out that people protected under Italy’s 2007 intelligence law, “including journalists”, had been monitored by the intelligence services “and therefore by the government” (translated from Italian) 8. It said the National Cybersecurity Agency had been told by WhatsApp’s lawyers that seven Italian accounts appeared to be affected 8.

The next day the Guardian and Haaretz reported, citing anonymous sources, that Paragon had cut ties with its Italian customers 9. Paragon’s executive chairman, John Fleming, told TechCrunch: “We have a zero-tolerance policy against such targeting.” 9 A European Commission spokesperson said any attempt to illegally access citizens’ data, including journalists’ data, was unacceptable if proven 10.

On 12 February Luca Ciriani, the minister for relations with parliament, told the Chamber of Deputies: “No one has terminated any contract with the intelligence services in recent days” (translated from Italian) 11. He added that “so far the government has not spied on journalists, but if anything has brought them to safety” (translated from Italian) 11. Two days later the government said it and Paragon had jointly agreed to suspend use of the tool pending an investigation 2.

What the forensic researchers found

In March 2025 the Citizen Lab at the University of Toronto reported that it had found traces of an artefact it calls BIGPRETZEL, which it attributes to Graphite infections, on the Android phones of Luca Casarini and Giuseppe Caccia of the migrant-rescue group Mediterranea Saving Humans 2. WhatsApp told Citizen Lab it believed the indicator was associated with Paragon 2. The traces dated from December 2024 and January 2025 2.

Citizen Lab did not find forensic confirmation of an infection on Cancellato’s Android phone 212. It said that “the absence of a finding of BIGPRETZEL on a particular device does not mean that the phone wasn’t successfully hacked”, because Android logs are sporadic 12.

On 12 June 2025 Citizen Lab said it had confirmed with high confidence that Ciro Pellegrino, who heads Fanpage.it’s Naples newsroom, and an anonymous European journalist had been targeted with Graphite after both received Apple threat notifications on 29 April 12. It said the anonymous journalist’s iPhone was infected in January and early February 2025 12. It linked both cases to the same Graphite customer through an iMessage account, and Apple assigned the zero-click flaw the identifier CVE-2025-43200 12. Citizen Lab said Paragon had not responded to its findings by the time of publication 12.

How it unfolded

  1. Key moment. Phones of Caccia, Casarini and Cancellato are attacked on the same night, prosecutors later say.

  2. Key moment. WhatsApp notifies about 90 users targeted with Paragon’s spyware, including Cancellato.

  3. Prime minister’s office denies intelligence monitored journalists; seven Italian accounts affected.

  4. Minister Ciriani tells parliament no contract with the intelligence services has been terminated.

  5. Citizen Lab publishes forensic evidence of Graphite on two activists’ phones.

  6. Key moment. COPASIR says intelligence lawfully targeted the activists but finds no evidence it targeted Cancellato.

  7. Paragon says it ended its Italian contracts; Italy’s intelligence department disputes its account.

  8. Citizen Lab confirms Graphite targeting of journalist Ciro Pellegrino.

  9. Consultant Francesco Nicodemo says he was also notified by WhatsApp.

  10. Key moment. Rome and Naples prosecutors confirm Cancellato’s phone was compromised, but not by AISI’s server.

  11. Paragon reported not to have answered prosecutors’ request sent via Israel.

  12. Paragon’s chief executive says the company cannot see customer misuse.

Parliament’s verdict and a public dispute

On 5 June 2025 COPASIR, the parliamentary committee that oversees the intelligence services, published its report 412. It said the foreign and domestic intelligence agencies, AISE and AISI, had used Graphite, and that Casarini and Caccia had been targeted lawfully, with authorisation, in investigations into alleged facilitation of illegal immigration 413.

The committee found no evidence that Italian intelligence had targeted Cancellato and said his number did not appear in the agencies’ records 413. It suggested Paragon’s foreign customers could potentially have targeted him, and it did not examine Pellegrino’s case 414.

Paragon then said it had offered the government and parliament a way to establish whether its system had been used against Cancellato, and that because the authorities “chose not to proceed with this solution, Paragon terminated its contracts in Italy” 13. The intelligence department DIS said it had rejected the offer on national security grounds and denied that the termination was unilateral 12. COPASIR said it had instead chosen to query Paragon’s databases directly 12.

Amnesty International said the Pellegrino case “confirms the rampant widening and systemic pattern of spyware abuse” 15. In November 2025 the political consultant Francesco Nicodemo, who has worked for the centre-left Democratic Party, said he had also received a WhatsApp notification in January 2025 1617. Citizen Lab confirmed he received it, though no forensic analysis of his phone has been published 16. “None of this looks good for Paragon, or for Italy,” said Citizen Lab’s John Scott-Railton 1618.

Prosecutors confirm the journalist was hacked

On 5 March 2026 the prosecutors’ offices of Rome and Naples said a technical report had found traces of malware on three Android phones among those handed over by complainants: those of Caccia, Casarini and Cancellato 1920. The attacks took place on the same night, 14 December 2024 56. Citizen Lab said the finding validated its own analysis of Cancellato’s phone 21.

Prosecutors said analysis of the Graphite server used by AISI showed operations against Casarini and Caccia that night but said the analysis “did not allow traces of operations attributable to Francesco Cancellato to be detected” (translated from Italian) 19. They said “investigations are continuing in order to identify the perpetrators of the attempted unlawful access and illegal interception against Francesco Cancellato” (translated from Italian) 19. The case is being pursued against unknown persons, and the heads of AISE and AISI were heard as witnesses 620.

The prosecutors’ experts did not find spyware traces on Pellegrino’s phone, a result that conflicts with Citizen Lab’s findings 57. Pellegrino said he was “pretty disconcerted” 5. The Italian government has denied being behind the hack of Cancellato and did not respond to TechCrunch’s request for comment 5. Scott-Railton said the confirmation “raises serious questions about why no confirmation was surfaced in prior official investigations by the Italian authorities” 5.

Where things stand

In April 2026 Wired Italy reported, according to TechCrunch, that prosecutors had sent a formal request for information to Paragon through the Israeli government and that the company had yet to respond 7. TechCrunch said the investigation was still under way 7. Paragon, which has since merged with the US company REDLattice, did not respond to TechCrunch’s request for comment in April 2026 167.

In an October 2026 interview with WIRED, summarised by Citizen Lab, Paragon’s chief executive Andrew Boyd said the company has no way to know whether customers misuse its software and has no “kill switch” to disable them 22.

Why it matters

In Italy a European Union government has acknowledged using commercial spyware against civil society figures, while researchers, a parliamentary committee and prosecutors have reached partly conflicting conclusions about the same phones 45. Paragon vowed to cut off customers who misuse its products, yet its chief executive says it cannot see how customers use its tool 22. Two journalists at the same news outlet were targeted, and in the latest reports, from April 2026, prosecutors had not identified who was responsible 1257.

Sources and references

  1. ArticleTechCrunch, “WhatsApp says it disrupted a hacking campaign targeting journalists with spyware”, 31 January 2025. Link
  2. ReportCitizen Lab, University of Toronto, “Virtue or Vice? A First Look at Paragon’s Proliferating Spyware Operations (Report No. 183)”, 19 March 2025. Link
  3. ArticleTechCrunch, “Journalist targeted on WhatsApp by Paragon spyware: ‘I feel violated’”, 3 February 2025. Link
  4. ArticleTechCrunch, “Italian lawmakers say Italy used spyware to target phones of immigration activists, but not against journalist”, 6 June 2025. Link
  5. ArticleTechCrunch, “Italian prosecutors confirm journalist was hacked with Paragon spyware”, 5 March 2026. Link
  6. ArticleSky TG24, “Caso Paragon, pm: ‘Spiati tre telefoni, anche attivisti e giornalista’”, 5 March 2026. Link
  7. ArticleTechCrunch, “Paragon is not collaborating with Italian authorities probing spyware attacks, report says”, 28 April 2026. Link
  8. Official documentPresidenza del Consiglio dei Ministri (Italian government), “Nota di Palazzo Chigi”, 5 February 2025. Link
  9. ArticleTechCrunch, “Spyware maker Paragon terminates contract with Italian government: Media reports”, 6 February 2025. Link
  10. ArticleEunews, “Paragon spyware case breaks out in Italy. European Commission: ‘Unacceptable if proven’”, 6 February 2025. Link
  11. ArticleOpen, “Caso Paragon, Ciriani alla Camera (question time)”, 12 February 2025. Link
  12. ReportCitizen Lab, University of Toronto, “Graphite Caught: First Forensic Confirmation of Paragon’s iOS Mercenary Spyware Finds Journalists Targeted (Report No. 186)”, 12 June 2025. Link
  13. ArticleThe Record (Recorded Future News), “Spyware maker cuts ties with Italy after government refused audit into hack of journalist’s phone”, 9 June 2025. Link
  14. ReportReuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, “Two Italian journalists’ phones were infiltrated with spyware. Nobody seems to know why”, 13 June 2025. Link
  15. ReportAmnesty International Security Lab, “Italy: New case of journalist targeted with Graphite spyware confirms widespread use of unlawful surveillance”, 13 June 2025. Link
  16. ArticleTechCrunch, “Italian political consultant says he was targeted with Paragon spyware”, 6 November 2025. Link
  17. ArticleThe Record (Recorded Future News), “Italian communications executive says he was targeted with Paragon spyware”, 6 November 2025. Link
  18. ReportCitizen Lab, University of Toronto, “John Scott-Railton on a New Paragon Infection in Italy”, 10 November 2025. Link
  19. ArticleIl Corriere del Giorno, “Caso Paragon, procure Roma e Napoli: ‘Effettuato accesso presso Aisi, nessuna traccia su Cancellato’”, 5 March 2026. Link
  20. ArticleAvvenire, “Caso Paragon, la procura conferma: malware su tre telefoni, ma Aisi non spio Cancellato”, 5 March 2026. Link
  21. ReportCitizen Lab, University of Toronto, “Italian Prosecutors Confirm Journalist Was Hacked with Paragon Spyware”, 18 March 2026. Link
  22. ReportCitizen Lab, University of Toronto, “The Secrets of a US Spyware King (In the Media: summary of WIRED interview)”, 8 October 2026. Link

Sources and references are provided for transparency and further reading. Allegations and claims are attributed to their respective sources. Triple Frontiers distinguishes reported allegations from independently established facts.

Spotted an error? Request a correction · Corrections policy

Share this story

Paragon spyware in Italy: who hacked the journalists and activists?

Newsroom desk Technology Desk

Technology, security and the digital economy. Stories are researched from official records, court documents, institutional reports and published journalism, with the help of AI research tools, and edited for Triple Frontiers. Every factual claim is linked to its source.

Newsletter

The Frontier Brief

The week’s essential international reporting and new investigations, every Friday.