Italy freed one Libyan suspect, Germany handed over another: the ICC’s Mitiga cases
Italy arrested Osama Elmasry Njeem on an ICC warrant in January 2025 and flew him home to Libya two days later. Judges found Italy in breach and referred it to the court's member states. Germany surrendered a second alleged Mitiga Prison leader, Khaled El Hishri, who is now committed to trial and denies the charges.

THE HAGUE On 19 January 2025 Italian police arrested Osama Elmasry Njeem in Turin on a warrant from the International Criminal Court (ICC) 12. Two days later Italy flew him back to Libya on a state flight, without handing him to the court 13. The ICC wants him over alleged crimes against humanity and war crimes, including murder, torture, rape and sexual violence, said to have been committed at Mitiga Prison in Tripoli from February 2015 24.
Nearly two years on, the case has produced a formal ICC finding against Italy, a referral of Italy to the court’s member states and a ruling by Italy’s Constitutional Court 156. A second alleged leader of the same prison, Khaled Mohamed Ali El Hishri, was arrested in Germany and is now awaiting trial in The Hague 7.
A warrant issued in a hurry
The ICC has had jurisdiction over Libya since the UN Security Council referred the situation to its prosecutor in February 2011 7. In May 2025 Libya also accepted the court’s jurisdiction over its territory from 2011 to the end of 2027 72.
The prosecution applied under seal for a warrant for Njeem on 2 October 2024 1. On 17 January 2025 it learned that he was in the Schengen area, and the next day Pre-Trial Chamber I issued the warrant by majority, with Judge María del Socorro Flores Liera dissenting 1. Requests for his provisional arrest went to six European states, including Italy 1. Human Rights Watch reports that the warrant alleges at least 34 killings 8.
Arrest and release in Italy
After the Turin arrest, the ICC registry repeatedly offered Italy consultations under the Rome Statute, but the Justice Ministry did not confirm when a hearing at the Rome Court of Appeal would take place 1. Italy returned Njeem to Libya on 21 January 2025 1.
Before the ICC, Italy argued that the Rome Court of Appeal had found the arrest unlawful under Law 237/2012, that Libya had made a competing extradition request, that the warrant was inconsistent, and that expelling Njeem was needed for national security 1. Interior Minister Matteo Piantedosi said the expulsion was made for reasons of state security 4.
Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni defended the decision. “On the merits I reaffirm the correctness of the conduct of the entire government,” she wrote, saying its “only compass” had been “protecting the security of Italians” (translated from Italian) 9.
The ICC’s finding against Italy
On 17 October 2025 Pre-Trial Chamber I unanimously found that Italy had failed to comply with its obligations under the Rome Statute, preventing the court from exercising its functions 1. The judges said “matters of domestic law cannot be invoked by a State Party to justify non-compliance” and that Italy “did not act with due diligence” 1. They noted that a corrected version of the warrant was issued only after Njeem had been returned 1.
By majority, the chamber first deferred a decision on whether to refer Italy to the Assembly of States Parties or the UN Security Council, and asked Rome for more information 1. On 26 January 2026, with Judge Iulia Motoc dissenting, it referred Italy to the Assembly, citing obstacles Italy had raised under its own law and the “ambiguous wording” of its assurances on future cooperation 510. Maurizio Gasparri, who leads Forza Italia’s senators, called the court’s members “people to be pitied” (translated from Italian) 10.
How it unfolded
-
ICC issues an arrest warrant for Osama Elmasry Njeem.
-
Key moment. Njeem is arrested in Turin.
-
Key moment. Italy flies him back to Libya.
-
Khaled El Hishri is arrested in Germany.
-
Italian deputies refuse to allow prosecution of two ministers and an undersecretary.
-
Key moment. ICC finds Italy failed to comply with its obligations.
-
Libya announces Njeem’s detention.
-
Germany surrenders El Hishri to the ICC.
-
ICC refers Italy to the Assembly of States Parties.
-
A Tripoli court sentences Njeem to seven years and four months.
-
Key moment. All 17 counts against El Hishri confirmed.
-
ICC upholds jurisdiction over Njeem; admissibility ruling deferred.
The case at home
In Italy, the Tribunal of Ministers archived its investigation into Meloni in August 2025 but sought to prosecute Justice Minister Carlo Nordio, Piantedosi and Undersecretary Alfredo Mantovano 9. A lawyer for a victim said the tribunal considered the conduct to amount to failure to perform official duties, aiding and abetting, and embezzlement 3. The government has defended their decisions as protecting national security 911.
On 9 October 2025 the Chamber of Deputies refused authorisation to proceed in secret ballots 311. “I am satisfied with the outcome of the vote,” Nordio said (translated from Italian) 3. The tribunal then archived the case against all three 12. Separately, Rome prosecutors have asked for Nordio’s former chief of staff, Giusi Bartolozzi, to be tried for alleged false statements in the case 13. She is presumed innocent.
In July 2026 the Constitutional Court ruled on a question raised by the Rome Court of Appeal in the case 614. It held Law 237/2012 partly unconstitutional because it did not require the Justice Minister to pass ICC cooperation requests immediately to the prosecutor general, unless he issues a reasoned refusal to protect overriding constitutional principles 6.
Germany hands over El Hishri
Pre-Trial Chamber I issued a warrant for El Hishri on 10 July 2025, and German federal police arrested him at Berlin Brandenburg Airport on 16 July 715. Germany surrendered him on 1 December 2025 7. German Justice Minister Stefanie Hubig called it “a successful example of realising the idea of international criminal law through international cooperation” (translated from German) 15. At his first appearance, El Hishri said he was “just requesting my release” 16.
On 16 July 2026 the same chamber unanimously confirmed all 17 counts against him and committed him to trial 78. The charges include torture, rape, murder, enslavement and persecution of detainees at Mitiga Prison, run by the Special Deterrence Force (SDF/RADA), between May 2014 and June 2020 7. The prosecution names Njeem as part of the prison’s leadership alongside El Hishri 7. El Hishri denies the charges 17. His defence argued that RADA was a legal body set up by government order and that he was never one of its leaders 7. A trial chamber was constituted on 20 July 2026 18.
Njeem in Libya
Libya announced Njeem’s detention on 5 November 2025, on the Attorney General’s order 194. On 21 June 2026 a Tripoli criminal court sentenced him to seven years and four months for violating detainees’ rights 420. The case reportedly concerned the torture of ten detainees and the death of one 208. Human Rights Watch said other sources indicated he was not in detention, and his whereabouts have not been made public 28.
Njeem’s lawyers have challenged the ICC case, arguing that the Libyan proceedings cover substantially the same conduct 218. On 2 November 2026 the pre-trial chamber unanimously upheld the court’s jurisdiction but deferred its ruling on admissibility, finding the Libyan documents too general, according to JusticeInfo 22. The defence and Libya must file further material by 29 January 2027 22.
The other Libya warrants
Human Rights Watch counts 14 people subject to public ICC warrants in the Libya situation; four have died or been killed and eight remain at large 8. Saif al-Islam Gaddafi, wanted since 2011, was killed by gunmen at his home in Zintan on 3 February 2026 and was never transferred to The Hague 2324. At least two suspects wanted over crimes in Tarhuna had reportedly been arrested in western Libya by November 2025 8.
Latest status
As of 18 November 2026, El Hishri is in ICC custody awaiting trial before Trial Chamber VII, and is presumed innocent 718. Njeem remains subject to the ICC warrant, his admissibility challenge is pending, and he too is presumed innocent of the ICC allegations 22. Italy’s non-compliance sits with the Assembly of States Parties 513.
Why it matters
Human Rights Watch calls El Hishri’s the first ICC Libya case to move to trial, and it depended on a European state making an arrest 87. Germany’s surrender and Italy’s release of a suspect wanted for related crimes produced opposite results 71. Whether a Libyan sentence can displace the ICC case against Njeem is now a question for the court’s judges 22.
Sources and references
- Court documentInternational Criminal Court (copy hosted by Giustizia Insieme), “Decision on Italy’s non-compliance with a request for cooperation (ICC-01/11-209), Pre-Trial Chamber I”, 17 October 2025. Link
- ReportHuman Rights Watch, “Libya: Surrender International Criminal Court Suspect”, 11 March 2026. Link
- ArticleLaPresse, “Caso Almasri, Camera nega autorizzazione a procedere per Nordio, Piantedosi e Mantovano”, 9 October 2025. Link
- ArticleIl Fatto Quotidiano, “[Report on the Tripoli sentence against Almasri; headline not captured]”, 21 June 2026. Link
- Court documentInternational Criminal Court (copy hosted by Sistema Penale), “Decision to refer Italy’s non-compliance with a request for cooperation to the Assembly of States Parties (ICC-01/11-224)”, 26 January 2026. Link
- Court documentCorte costituzionale (Italy), “Sentenza n. 143 del 2026”, 23 July 2026. Link
- Court documentInternational Criminal Court (copy hosted by Courthouse News), “Decision on confirmation of the charges against Mr Khaled Mohamed Ali El Hishri (ICC-01/11-01/25-143)”, 16 July 2026. Link
- ReportHuman Rights Watch, “Libya: ICC Greenlights First Case to Move to Trial”, 16 July 2026. Link
- ArticleLaPresse, “Caso Almasri, Giorgia Meloni: ‘Mia posizione archiviata, ribadirò la correttezza del nostro operato’”, 4 August 2025. Link
- ArticleLaPresse, “Caso Almasri, Italia deferita all’Assemblea degli Stati della Cpi”, 26 January 2026. Link
- ArticleAvvenire, “Almasri: la Camera dice no al processo”, 9 October 2025. Link
- ArticleLaPresse, “Caso Almasri, Tribunale dei ministri archivia procedimento su Nordio-Piantedosi-Mantovano”, 28 October 2025. Link
- ArticleLaPresse, “Caso Almasri, Assemblea Cpi deferisce l’Italia. I Pm: rinvio a giudizio per Giusi Bartolozzi”, 2 April 2026. Link
- ArticlePagella Politica, “Che cosa cambia nel caso Almasri dopo la sentenza della Corte costituzionale”, 28 July 2026. Link
- ArticleLegal Tribune Online, “[LTO report on Germany’s surrender of El Hishri to the ICC; headline not captured]”, 2 December 2025. Link
- ArticleTRT World / Anadolu Agency, “ICC sets May 2026 hearing for Libyan war crimes suspect El Hishri”. Link
- ArticleTRT World, “ICC rules Libya war crimes suspect must stand trial”. Link
- ReportCoalition for the International Criminal Court, “ICC confirms all charges against Khaled El Hishri and commits first Libya case to trial”, 29 July 2026. Link
- ReportCoalition for the International Criminal Court / Libya Crimes Watch, “The ICC, Non-Cooperation and the Cost of Impunity in Libya: Lessons from 2025”, 6 January 2026. Link
- ArticleAvvenire, “La condanna di Almasri (a Tripoli): 7 anni e 4 mesi per aver violato i diritti dei detenuti”, 22 June 2026. Link
- ArticleLaPresse, “Libia, Almasri presenta ricorso contro la Corte Penale Internazionale”, 20 May 2026. Link
- ArticleJusticeInfo.net (Catherine Maia), “ICC: How far does a UN Security Council referral extend?”, 16 November 2026. Link
- ArticleJusticeInfo.net (Janet H. Anderson), “Gaddafi’s death, the last nail in an ICC coffin”, 5 February 2026. Link
- ArticleMiddle East Eye, “[Report on the killing of Saif al-Islam Gaddafi; headline not captured]”, 4 February 2026. Link
Sources and references are provided for transparency and further reading. Allegations and claims are attributed to their respective sources. Triple Frontiers distinguishes reported allegations from independently established facts.
The Frontier Brief
The week’s essential international reporting and new investigations, every Friday.



