Triple Frontiers
Retrospective · AI

OpenAI’s restructuring: the nonprofit deal, Microsoft’s new terms and Musk’s failed lawsuit

In October 2025 OpenAI turned its business into a public benefit corporation controlled by a nonprofit, after two state attorneys-general set conditions, and signed a new deal with Microsoft. A year on, a jury has rejected Elon Musk's core claims as filed too late, the Microsoft deal has been rewritten again and OpenAI is preparing to list.

RetrospectiveEvents of 28 October 2025. Published by Triple Frontiers on 18 November 2026 as part of our archive covering events before our launch, based on the sources listed below.
A modern multi-storey office building on a San Francisco street corner
The office building at 1515 Third Street in San Francisco's Mission Bay, which housed OpenAI's headquarters when photographed (file photo, 2025).Photo: Coolcaesar / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

On 28 October 2025 OpenAI said it had completed a recapitalisation that turned its for-profit arm into a public benefit corporation, OpenAI Group PBC, and renamed its nonprofit parent the OpenAI Foundation 12. The change came after the attorneys-general of Delaware and California said they would not oppose it 2. The same day Microsoft announced a new agreement with OpenAI, saying its investment was valued at approximately $135 billion, roughly 27% on an as-converted diluted basis 3.

According to CNBC, the foundation holds 26% of the for-profit, a stake worth about $130 billion, while current and former employees and investors hold 47% 1. OpenAI was valued at $500 billion at the time 12.

From conversion to compromise

Delaware’s attorney-general, Kathy Jennings, began reviewing OpenAI’s plans on 9 October 2024 4. Her office hired independent counsel and the financial adviser Moelis & Company, and worked with the office of California’s attorney-general, Rob Bonta 4.

In February 2025 a Musk-led investor group offered $97.4 billion to buy control of the nonprofit that oversees OpenAI; its chief executive, Sam Altman, rebuffed the offer as an effort to “slow down a competitor” 5. On 4 March 2025 a federal judge in California rejected Musk’s request to halt the conversion, saying the plaintiffs “failed to meet their burden of proof for the extraordinary relief requested”, while allowing other parts of his lawsuit to proceed 5.

On 5 May 2025 OpenAI reversed course and said its nonprofit would keep control of the business, which would become a public benefit corporation 6. It said the decision followed “constructive dialogue” with the Delaware and California attorneys-general 6. In September Microsoft and OpenAI signed a nonbinding memorandum of understanding, and OpenAI’s chairman, Bret Taylor, said the nonprofit’s stake would be “worth upward of $100 billion” 7.

The attorneys-general’s conditions

On 28 October 2025 Jennings issued a Statement of No Objection 4. Under its terms the nonprofit keeps sole power to appoint and remove the PBC’s directors, and on safety and security issues those directors may consider only the mission, not shareholders’ financial interests 4. A Safety and Security Committee stays with the nonprofit and can require mitigation measures “up to and including halting the release of models or AI systems” 4. Within a year, at least two nonprofit directors must not also sit on the PBC board 42.

“These reforms are designed to help this technology realize its extraordinary potential to benefit humanity,” Jennings said 4. Bonta said: “We will be keeping a close eye on OpenAI to ensure ongoing adherence to its charitable mission” 2. Taylor said in a blog post that “the nonprofit remains in control of the for-profit, and now has a direct path to major resources before AGI arrives” 2. Robert Weissman, co-president of the advocacy group Public Citizen, called that control “illusory because there is no evidence of the nonprofit ever imposing its values on the for-profit” 2. The foundation said it would commit $25 billion to health, curing diseases and protecting against AI cybersecurity risks, without giving a time period 2.

Microsoft’s new terms

Under the October agreement, any OpenAI declaration that it has reached artificial general intelligence (AGI) “will now be verified by an independent expert panel”, Microsoft said 3. Microsoft’s rights to OpenAI’s models and products were extended through 2032, it kept exclusive access to OpenAI’s models through its Azure cloud until AGI, and OpenAI contracted to buy an additional $250 billion of Azure services 31. Microsoft gave up its right of first refusal to be OpenAI’s computing provider 3.

The two companies rewrote the deal on 27 April 2026, when Microsoft said it would no longer pay a revenue share to OpenAI, that OpenAI’s revenue-share payments to Microsoft would continue through 2030 subject to a total cap, and that its licence to OpenAI’s technology through 2032 would become non-exclusive 8. OpenAI can now sell its products through any cloud provider, though Azure remains its primary cloud and products ship there first 89. CNBC reported, citing a source, that OpenAI still pays Microsoft 20% of revenue; the size of the cap was not disclosed 9.

How it unfolded

  1. Delaware’s attorney-general begins reviewing OpenAI’s conversion plans.

  2. Musk-led group offers $97.4bn for control of the nonprofit; rebuffed.

  3. Judge refuses Musk’s request to halt the conversion.

  4. OpenAI says its nonprofit will keep control.

  5. Microsoft and OpenAI sign a nonbinding memorandum of understanding.

  6. Key moment. Recapitalisation completed; Delaware and California do not object; new Microsoft deal.

  7. Microsoft deal amended; Musk trial begins in Oakland.

  8. Key moment. Jury finds Musk’s claims time-barred; judge adopts verdict.

  9. OpenAI says it has confidentially filed for a listing.

  10. Mediator appointed for Musk’s remaining claims.

  11. Key moment. Reuters reports funding at a $1.25tn valuation.

Musk’s lawsuit

In January 2026 the judge, Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, rejected OpenAI’s and Microsoft’s requests to dismiss Musk’s case and sent it to a jury, while throwing out a claim that Microsoft had been enriched at his expense 10. Musk asked the court to remove Altman and OpenAI’s president, Greg Brockman, and to unwind the recapitalisation 1112. A January 2026 filing sought up to $134 billion in “wrongful gains”, according to CNBC, which later put the figure sought at up to $180 billion; Musk said any money should go to the OpenAI charity 1113.

Jury selection began in Oakland on 27 April 2026 11. On 18 May the nine-member advisory jury unanimously found that he had brought his claims too late, after deliberating for less than two hours, and the judge adopted the verdict 11141315. The claims tried were breach of charitable trust and unjust enrichment, and the jury did not decide whether Musk had actually been misled 12. “There’s a substantial amount of evidence to support the jury’s finding,” Gonzalez Rogers said 14.

Musk wrote that “the judge & jury never actually ruled on the merits of the case, just on a calendar technicality” and said he would appeal to the Ninth Circuit 1213. OpenAI’s lead lawyer, William Savitt, said: “It’s not a technical decision, it’s a substantive one” 13. A Microsoft lawyer said the company would “welcome the jury’s decision to dismiss these claims as untimely” 13.

The case is not over. Musk and his company xAI also brought antitrust and related claims, including under the Sherman and Clayton Acts 1617. On 10 June 2026 the judge said she had “concerns regarding the viability of these causes of action given the fierce competition in the AI field” 17. On 1 July she appointed a mediator, R. David Proctor, for all claims that have not reached final judgment, and conditionally named him special master for the antitrust claims if mediation fails 18. On 10 August Musk and xAI filed their answer to OpenAI’s counterclaims for unfair competition and tortious interference 19. District court filings from July and August 2026 show those claims and OpenAI’s counterclaims still pending, with a mediator appointed for the claims that had not reached final judgment 1819.

Latest status

OpenAI said in June 2026 that it had submitted a confidential draft listing prospectus to US regulators and had not decided on timing 20. That month, CNBC reported a coalition of state attorneys-general had opened an investigation into OpenAI’s handling of advertising, consumer and health data and young and older users, and OpenAI said it would “engage constructively” 21. In August its finance chief, Sarah Friar, told staff the company “will be a public company in 2027”, according to two people familiar with her remarks 22.

OpenAI raised $122 billion in late March 2026 at a valuation of more than $850 billion, according to CNBC 13. On 6 November Reuters reported, citing a source, that OpenAI had closed $11 billion as the first part of a new round valuing it at $1.25 trillion, below the $1.5 trillion it had initially sought 2324.

Why it matters

The restructuring fixed a governance model in which a nonprofit controls a company that Reuters reports is valued at $1.25 trillion, with state attorneys-general holding conditions on safety and board control 423. Microsoft’s position has shifted from exclusive partner to large shareholder with a non-exclusive licence 8. The May verdict removed Musk’s central challenge to the new structure without deciding whether OpenAI kept its founding promises, and his remaining claims are still before the court 1218.

Sources and references

  1. ArticleCNBC, “OpenAI completes restructure, solidifying Microsoft as a major shareholder”, 28 October 2025. Link
  2. ArticleAssociated Press via WDIV, “OpenAI says it has new for-profit business structure, adjusts partnership with Microsoft (AP)”, 28 October 2025. Link
  3. Official documentMicrosoft, “The next chapter of the Microsoft–OpenAI partnership”, 28 October 2025. Link
  4. Official documentState of Delaware, “AG Jennings completes review of OpenAI recapitalization”, 28 October 2025. Link
  5. ArticleCNBC, “Judge denies Musk’s attempt to block OpenAI from becoming for-profit entity”, 4 March 2025. Link
  6. ArticleTechCrunch, “OpenAI reverses course, says its nonprofit will remain in control of its business operations”, 5 May 2025. Link
  7. ArticleTechCrunch, “OpenAI secures Microsoft’s blessing to transition its for-profit arm”, 11 September 2025. Link
  8. Official documentMicrosoft, “The next phase of the Microsoft-OpenAI partnership”, 27 April 2026. Link
  9. ArticleCNBC, “OpenAI shakes up partnership with Microsoft, capping revenue share payments”, 27 April 2026. Link
  10. ArticleTechCrunch, “Silicon Valley’s messiest breakup is definitely headed to court”, 15 January 2026. Link
  11. ArticleCNBC, “OpenAI trial day 2 takeaways”, 28 April 2026. Link
  12. ArticleMIT Technology Review, “Here’s why Elon Musk lost his suit against OpenAI”, 18 May 2026. Link
  13. ArticleCNBC, “Musk slams Altman trial verdict as a ‘technicality,’ vows to appeal”, 18 May 2026. Link
  14. ArticleReuters via Business Day, “Elon Musk loses high-stakes lawsuit against OpenAI over company’s mission (Reuters)”, 18 May 2026. Link
  15. ArticleAssociated Press via WTOP, “OpenAI avoided a costly court loss to Elon Musk, but neither side is unscathed (AP)”, 19 May 2026. Link
  16. Court documentUS District Court, N.D. California (via CourtListener RECAP), “Joint stipulation and proposed order regarding answer (Dkt. 607)”, 2 July 2026. Link
  17. Court documentUS District Court, N.D. California (via CourtListener RECAP), “Order for joint briefing schedule re: remaining claims (Dkt. 602), Musk v. Altman, 4:24-cv-04722-YGR”, 10 June 2026. Link
  18. Court documentUS District Court, N.D. California (via CourtListener RECAP), “Order appointing mediator and conditionally appointing special master (Dkt. 606)”, 1 July 2026. Link
  19. Court documentUS District Court, N.D. California (via CourtListener RECAP), “Plaintiffs’ answer and defenses to the OpenAI defendants’ amended counterclaims (Dkt. 609)”, 10 August 2026. Link
  20. ArticleCNBC, “CNBC Daily Open: Hat trick of tech IPOs complete with OpenAI filing”, 9 June 2026. Link
  21. ArticleCNBC, “OpenAI says it’s engaging ‘constructively’ with state AGs about concerns”, 12 June 2026. Link
  22. ArticleCNBC, “OpenAI ‘will be a public company in 2027’ or sooner, CFO Friar tells employees”, 19 August 2026. Link
  23. ArticleReuters via bdnews24, “OpenAI gets $11 billion funding at $1.25 trillion valuation (Reuters)”, 7 November 2026. Link
  24. ArticleReuters via DealStreetAsia, “OpenAI gets $11b funding at $1.25t valuation (Reuters)”, 7 November 2026. Link

Sources and references are provided for transparency and further reading. Allegations and claims are attributed to their respective sources. Triple Frontiers distinguishes reported allegations from independently established facts.

Spotted an error? Request a correction · Corrections policy

Share this story

OpenAI’s restructuring: the nonprofit deal, Microsoft’s new terms and Musk’s failed lawsuit

Newsroom desk Technology Desk

Technology, security and the digital economy. Stories are researched from official records, court documents, institutional reports and published journalism, with the help of AI research tools, and edited for Triple Frontiers. Every factual claim is linked to its source.

Newsletter

The Frontier Brief

The week’s essential international reporting and new investigations, every Friday.