
Pangolins, ivory and rhino horn: tracking the Africa-Asia trafficking routes
UNODC found rhino horn, pangolin scales and ivory among the largest illegal wildlife markets. Seizures have fallen since 2019 and routes have shifted, while Nigerian courts convict traffickers and CITES has kept stockpile sales banned.
Key findings
- UNODC’s 2024 report found rhinoceros, pangolins and elephants made up 29%, 28% and 15% of the animal markets observed in 2015-2021 seizures, and said ivory and rhino horn poaching, seizures and prices had declined. Confirmed
- WJC analysis counted more than 370 tonnes of pangolin scales and 193 tonnes of ivory seized in 2015-2024; 2024 volumes were 84% and 74% below 2019, figures compiled by the NGO. Confirmed
- A Lagos court convicted Steven Chinonso in November 2025 over pangolin scales and sentenced him to one year; suspected trafficker Shamsideen Abubakar was arrested in April 2026 and remains a suspect. Confirmed
- South Africa said 352 rhinos were poached in 2025, down from 420, but Kruger losses rose from 88 to 175; TRAFFIC and IUCN put Africa’s rhino population down 6.7%, to about 22,540. Confirmed
- CITES CoP20 rejected Namibia’s bids to sell rhino horn and ivory stocks in December 2025; Namibia argued regulated trade would fund conservation. Confirmed
Confirmedbacked by documents or on-record sourcesAllegedclaimed by sources, not provenDisputedcontested by the parties involved
On 13 May 2024 the UN Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) published its third World Wildlife Crime Report, which found that seizures between 2015 and 2021 pointed to illegal trade in 162 countries and territories, affecting around 4,000 plant and animal species 12. By UNODC’s standardised seizure index, rhinoceros accounted for 29 per cent of the animal markets observed, pangolins 28 per cent and elephants 15 per cent 2. UNODC said trafficking overall had not been substantially reduced over two decades, although poaching, seizure levels and market prices for elephant ivory and rhino horn had “declined solidly” over the past decade 1.
Triple Frontiers reviewed the UNODC report, outcomes of the 2025 meeting of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES), government and court announcements from South Africa, Hong Kong and the United States, and seizure analyses by the Wildlife Justice Commission (WJC), TRAFFIC and the Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA) to establish what has been found about the trade in pangolin scales, ivory and rhino horn from Africa to Asia since 2024.
What UNODC found
UNODC said that after pivotal arrests in Kenya and Tanzania, from about 2015 Nigeria became the primary country of ivory exports from Africa 3. Viet Nam and Cambodia became increasingly prominent destinations in 2015-2019, and mixed loads of tusks and pangolin scales appeared around the same time 3. Wholesale ivory prices in destination markets in 2018 were one-third of their 2014 level, it said 3. At sites monitored under the CITES elephant programme, the share of carcasses found to have been illegally killed fell from 56 per cent in 2012 to 16 per cent in 2022 3.
Pangolin scale seizures followed a different curve 3. They peaked in 2019, when Singapore made the three largest seizures on record, of 12,913 kg and 12,768 kg in April and 11,912 kg in July, before falling sharply in 2020 3. More than 130 tonnes of scales were seized in 2018 and 2019 in shipments from Nigeria, UNODC said, and where the departure country was recorded, more than 60 per cent of shipments in 2015-2021 left from Nigeria 3. Mainland China and Hong Kong were the largest reported destinations, with Viet Nam a secondary destination since 2019 3. China removed pangolin scales from its official traditional medicine pharmacopoeia in 2020 3.
UNODC also said corruption plays a key role in undermining enforcement, but wildlife cases are seldom prosecuted as corruption offences, even though anti-corruption laws often carry higher penalties 1. It counted 164 UN member states that criminalise wildlife crime to some degree, of which 86 set maximum penalties of at least four years 2.
Seizures fall after 2019
A 2025 analysis by the WJC, a non-profit investigations group, counted more than 370 tonnes of pangolin scales and more than 193 tonnes of ivory seized worldwide between 2015 and 2024 45. It estimated these represented between 100,000 and one million pangolins and about 19,300 elephants 4. In 2020 the volume of scales seized fell 75 per cent from 2019 and ivory 94 per cent; by 2024 volumes were 84 and 74 per cent below 2019 levels 45. Multi-ton seizures fell from 65 in 2015-2019 to 29 in 2020-2024 4.
The WJC said no significant pangolin scale seizure had been reported at any seaport for three years, the last being 6.2 tonnes at Da Nang, Viet Nam, in January 2022 4. It linked the decline to pandemic disruption, sustained enforcement and falling prices 45. Others urged caution 5. “It is possible that trafficking is down because the populations have crashed,” Susan Lieberman of the Wildlife Conservation Society told Mongabay 5.
How it unfolded
-
Lagos court sentences four traffickers to six years or fines.
-
CITES trade suspension against Angola takes effect, EIA reports.
-
Mozambique seizes 651 ivory pieces bound for Dubai.
-
Key moment. UNODC publishes World Wildlife Crime Report 2024.
-
Key moment. Nigeria seizes 9.4 tonnes of pangolin scales in Ogun and Kaduna.
-
Suspected Chinese trafficker arrested in Lagos.
-
3.765 tonnes of scales seized in Lagos; five arrested.
-
TRAFFIC/IUCN rhino report: poaching lowest since 2011.
-
Steven Chinonso convicted in Lagos.
-
Key moment. CITES CoP20 ends with stockpile sales rejected.
-
South Africa reports 352 rhinos poached in 2025.
-
Hong Kong court jails rhino horn smuggler for 24 months.
-
Key moment. Shamsideen Abubakar arrested in Nigeria.
-
US sentences in Oregon-Vietnam wildlife case announced.
Nigeria: seizures, arrests and convictions
Nigeria has remained a hub for pangolin scales, according to the WJC 4. On 8 August 2024 the Nigeria Customs Service (NCS), acting on WJC intelligence, seized 7.2 tonnes of scales in a warehouse in Ogun state and 2.294 tonnes in Kaduna, arresting four suspects 67. The WJC said the Ogun haul was the largest pangolin scale seizure globally since January 2020 and valued the two stockpiles at more than US$1.7 million at the Asian end of the supply chain 6.
On 19 February 2025 customs officers arrested a suspected high-level Chinese trafficker in Lagos whom the WJC linked to the Ogun stockpile; the releases reviewed did not name him 8. On 2 April 2025 officers arrested five suspects and seized 3.765 tonnes of scales at Lagos’s Jakande Market and a warehouse in Efiran, an amount the WJC estimated represented more than 1,900 pangolins 9.
On 7 November 2025 the Federal High Court in Lagos convicted Steven Chinonso, also known as Chukwunonso Stephen Obunadike, of conspiracy, unlawful possession and illegal sale of pangolin scales 10. He had been arrested on 2 April 2025 after officers seized 1,003.9 kg of scales in March, and was sentenced to one year’s imprisonment on each count, to run concurrently 10. In July 2023 the same court sentenced three Vietnamese nationals, Phan Viet Chi, Phan Hong Quan and Duong Van Thang, and a Guinean, Mory Berrette, to six years each or fines in lieu after they pleaded guilty over 7.1 tonnes of pangolin scales and 850 kg of ivory 11.
On 23 April 2026 the WJC announced the arrest of Shamsideen Abubakar, a suspected high-level trafficker who had been declared wanted by the Federal High Court in Lagos and had evaded capture since September 2021 12. The WJC describes him as a suspect, and he is presumed innocent 12. The WJC said in November 2025 that its partnership with customs since 2021 had produced 42 arrests and 13 convictions 10. It said a newly passed endangered species bill would allow sentences of up to 10 years 10.
Ivory moves to Mozambique and Angola
The WJC found that from 2022 ivory shipments to Asia began moving through Angola and Mozambique, while Nigerian routes remained in use 45. On 22 March 2024 Mozambican officials found 651 pieces of ivory, bound for Dubai and concealed in bags of corn, in a container at Maputo port 13. EIA later put the seizure at 4.8 tonnes 14. By EIA’s database, Mozambique was the country most implicated in global ivory seizures by weight in 2022-24, and Angola was linked to more than eight tonnes, including 7.5 tonnes of raw ivory seized in Viet Nam in 2023 14.
EIA reported that a CITES recommendation to suspend commercial trade in listed species with Angola took effect on 10 January 2024, over inadequate progress on its ivory action plan 15. In a November 2025 briefing, EIA said the CITES ivory trade monitoring report to the 2025 conference had flagged Angola and Mozambique for escalation, and that China accounted for 56 per cent of worked ivory seizures worldwide in 2021-23 14. The WJC report cited the conviction in Mozambique on 21 March 2024 of Chabane Assuba, whom it described as a supplier to a Vietnamese network, with a 30-year sentence 4.
Rhino horn: fewer poached, fewer rhinos
A report by TRAFFIC and the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) for CITES, published in August 2025, found poaching accounted for 2.15 per cent of Africa’s rhinos in 2024, the lowest rate since 2011 16. Africa’s rhino population nonetheless fell 6.7 per cent to about 22,540, with white rhinos down more than 11 per cent 16. Between 2021 and 2023 about 1.8 tonnes of horn was seized worldwide, with South Africa accounting for 66 per cent by weight and significant shipments bound for Malaysia and Viet Nam 1617.
South Africa’s environment minister, Willie Aucamp, said 352 rhinos were poached in 2025, down from 420 in 2024, but losses in Kruger National Park rose from 88 to 175 18. His department said ZM Muiambo, alias Thomas Chauke, was found guilty in the High Court in Makhanda on 19 charges including illegal hunting of rhinos and was sentenced to 20 years in April 2025 18.
At the receiving end, Hong Kong Customs seized about 2.7 kg of suspected rhino horn in parcels from Spain on 11 July 2025 and arrested two men 19. On 26 February 2026 a Hong Kong court sentenced a man who had arrived from Dhaka with 41 pieces of rhino horn, weighing 7.7 kg, to 24 months after he pleaded guilty 20. In the United States, Teo Boon Ching, described by the WJC as a major Malaysian transporter, was sentenced in New York in September 2023 to 18 months over a conspiracy to traffic more than 70 kg of rhino horn 214. On 23 October 2026 the Justice Department said a California couple had been sentenced to probation for processing payments for wildlife moved between Oregon and Vietnam, including rhino horn segments 22.
CITES keeps the stockpiles closed
CITES parties met in Samarkand, Uzbekistan, from 24 November to 5 December 2025, and rejected proposals to reopen trade in government-held ivory and rhino horn stocks 2324. Namibia’s proposal on white rhino horn was defeated with 69.31 per cent against, its black rhino proposal with 74.07 per cent against and its ivory proposal by 81 votes to 22, with 14 abstentions 2425. Namibia had sought to sell more than 44,000 kg of ivory from its stockpiles 25. “The proposals would have been untraceable, unmanageable and unenforceable,” said James Isiche, Africa director of the International Fund for Animal Welfare 24.
Where things stand
The WJC’s April 2026 release on Shamsideen Abubakar describes him as a suspected trafficker under arrest, and its March 2025 release describes the Chinese national arrested in Lagos as a suspect 812. South Africa’s 2025 figures show national poaching down 16 per cent while Kruger losses nearly doubled 18. In the US case announced in October 2026, the two defendants received probation and fines 22. CITES’s ban on commercial trade in rhino horn and ivory stockpiles remains in place 24.
Why it matters
UNODC and NGO data agree that seizures of ivory, rhino horn and pangolin scales fell from 2019 peaks, but one conservation researcher has cautioned that lower seizures could also mean populations have crashed 45. The routes have shifted rather than closed, from Nigeria towards Angola and Mozambique for ivory 414. UNODC’s call for traffickers to be prosecuted under anti-corruption laws, which often carry higher penalties, sits against sentences such as one year in Lagos and 24 months in Hong Kong 11020.
The documents
-
UNODC: World Wildlife Crime Report 2024May 2024. Ivory p.197; rhino p.211; pangolin scales pp.223-230.Read (UNODC: World Wildlife Crime Report 2024)
-
UNODC: WWCR 2024 summary and policy implicationsKey figures p.6; trends pp.14-17.Read (UNODC: WWCR 2024 summary and policy implications)
-
WJC: Disruption and Disarray, 2015-202472 pp. Key findings pp.6-7, 20-25; export hubs pp.36-37.Read (WJC: Disruption and Disarray, 2015-2024)
-
EIA: briefing to CITES SC79 on ivory action plansNovember 2025. China, UAE, Angola, Mozambique pp.3-7.Read (EIA: briefing to CITES SC79 on ivory action plans)
-
Council of the EU: note on CITES CoP2012 December 2025. Ivory and rhino outcome p.4.Read (Council of the EU: note on CITES CoP20)
-
South Africa: 2025 rhino poaching statement10 February 2026.Open (South Africa: 2025 rhino poaching statement)
-
TRAFFIC: rhino report for CITES CoP207 August 2025.Open (TRAFFIC: rhino report for CITES CoP20)
-
Hong Kong government: rhino horn sentence26 February 2026.Open (Hong Kong government: rhino horn sentence)
-
US Justice Department: Oregon wildlife trafficking sentences23 October 2026.Open (US Justice Department: Oregon wildlife trafficking sentences)
-
WJC: Steven Chinonso conviction14 November 2025.Open (WJC: Steven Chinonso conviction)
The Chinese national arrested in Lagos in February 2025 has not been named in the releases reviewed 8. Phan Viet Chi, Phan Hong Quan, Duong Van Thang and Mory Berrette changed their pleas to guilty under a plea bargain in July 2023 11. The man sentenced in Hong Kong in February 2026 pleaded guilty 20, and Linh Luu and Kevin Le pleaded guilty to Lacey Act violations 22. Namibia’s environment ministry had not responded to Namibian Sun queries at the time of the vote; in its submission Namibia argued that regulated rhino horn trade could generate sustainable conservation funding while undermining the black market 25. Jaco Muller, chairperson of the private rhino owners’ group Help Our Rhinos Now Namibia, said: “We are very disappointed, but in 2022 the yes votes were only 15%. Now it was 30%, so at least that is positive.” 25 Triple Frontiers did not contact those named directly; their positions are taken from published statements.
How we reported this
This investigation is a review of public records: the UNODC World Wildlife Crime Report 2024 and its summary; a Council of the European Union note on CITES CoP20; statements by South Africa’s Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment, the Hong Kong government and the US Justice Department; releases and a 72-page report by the Wildlife Justice Commission; briefings by the Environmental Investigation Agency; TRAFFIC’s summary of its rhino report for CITES; an IFAW release; and reporting by Mongabay, Yale Environment 360, The Namibian and the Namibian Sun. UNODC’s seizure data run to 2021; WJC, EIA and TRAFFIC figures are compiled by those organisations from seizures and intelligence and are attributed to them. The CITES website and an IISD conference report blocked automated access, so CITES documents were read through secondary summaries. We excluded claims we could not trace to a source we opened, including a reported 2025 ivory seizure in Da Nang, the current status of the CITES trade suspension against Angola, and the Nigeria Customs Service’s own statements on the August 2024 seizure. Seizures measure enforcement as well as trafficking and do not show how much contraband goes undetected.
Sources and references
- ReportUNODC, “UNODC press release on World Wildlife Crime Report 2024”, 13 May 2024. Link
- ReportUNODC, “World Wildlife Crime Report 2024: summary, conclusions and policy implications”, 13 May 2024. Link
- ReportUNODC, “World Wildlife Crime Report 2024 (full report)”, 13 May 2024. Link
- ReportWildlife Justice Commission, “Disruption and Disarray: pangolin scale and ivory trafficking 2015-2024”. Link
- ArticleMongabay, “Pandemic-era slump in ivory and pangolin scale trafficking persists, report finds”, June 2025. Link
- ReportWildlife Justice Commission, “Warehouse raids in Nigeria lead to historic seizure of over 9.4 tonnes”, 17 October 2024. Link
- ArticleYale Environment 360, “Nine tons of illicit pangolin scales recovered in Nigeria”, 17 October 2024. Link
- ReportWildlife Justice Commission, “Suspected wildlife trafficking kingpin arrested in Nigeria”, 31 March 2025. Link
- ReportWildlife Justice Commission, “Five arrested and 3.765 tonnes of pangolin scales seized”, 8 April 2025. Link
- ReportWildlife Justice Commission, “Nigerian wildlife trafficker convicted”, 14 November 2025. Link
- ReportWildlife Justice Commission, “Three Vietnamese and one Guinean convicted in Nigeria”, 21 July 2023. Link
- ReportWildlife Justice Commission, “After five years on the run, high-level wildlife trafficker arrested”, 23 April 2026. Link
- ReportEnvironmental Investigation Agency, “Large ivory seizure in Mozambique”, 27 March 2024. Link
- ReportEnvironmental Investigation Agency, “CITES National Ivory Action Plan process: EIA briefing to SC79”, November 2025. Link
- ReportEnvironmental Investigation Agency, “Angola hit with trade sanctions over elephant poaching and ivory trafficking”, 15 February 2024. Link
- ReportTRAFFIC, “Rhino poaching falls, but populations still at risk”, 7 August 2025. Link
- ArticleThe Namibian, “Namibia loses bid to overturn ban on rhino horn trade (BBC)”, 6 December 2025. Link
- Official documentGovernment of South Africa (DFFE), “Minister Willie Aucamp on 16% decline in rhino poaching”, 10 February 2026. Link
- Official documentHong Kong SAR Government, “Hong Kong Customs seizes suspected scheduled rhino horns worth about $1 million”, 16 July 2025. Link
- Official documentHong Kong SAR Government, “Man sentenced to 24 months’ imprisonment for smuggling rhino horns”, 26 February 2026. Link
- ReportWildlife Justice Commission, “WJC congratulates USFWS following conviction of Teo Boon Ching”, 20 September 2023. Link
- Official documentUS Department of Justice, “California couple sentenced for trafficking protected wildlife”, 23 October 2026. Link
- Official documentCouncil of the European Union, “Council note on CITES CoP20 outcomes (16410/1/25 REV 1)”, 12 December 2025. Link
- ReportIFAW, “Bids to remove protections for Africa’s iconic wildlife fail”, 29 November 2025. Link
- ArticleNamibian Sun, “CITES votes no to Namibia’s ivory, rhino horn trade proposal”, 3 December 2025. Link
Sources and references are provided for transparency and further reading. Allegations and claims are attributed to their respective sources. Triple Frontiers distinguishes reported allegations from independently established facts.
Corrections and updates
The Frontier Brief
The week’s essential international reporting and new investigations, every Friday.


