Triple Frontiers
Aerial view of a large prison complex of grey buildings and walls surrounded by green countryside
Investigation · Politics

The Alien Enemies Act flights: how Venezuelans were sent to El Salvador’s CECOT

In March 2025 the US flew Venezuelan men it called Tren de Aragua members to a Salvadoran prison while a judge was trying to stop it. Most had no US convictions, rights groups allege torture, and the courts are still deciding who answers for the flights.

By Investigations Desk · Published 18 Nov 2026 · 9 min read · 6 source documents

Photo: Casa Presidencial, El Salvador / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

Key findings

  1. The US flew 252 Venezuelan men, 137 of them under the Alien Enemies Act, to El Salvador on 15 March 2025 during a court hearing on the removals, according to Judge Boasberg’s opinion. Confirmed
  2. Of 238 men analysed by ProPublica and partners, 32 had US convictions and six for violent crimes; DHS says the men were gang members who lacked US rap sheets. Disputed
  3. HRW and Cristosal allege systematic beatings, sexual violence and enforced disappearance at CECOT; the US and El Salvador did not respond to them. Alleged
  4. Boasberg ruled in December 2025 that the men were in US constructive custody and were denied due process; the government is appealing. Confirmed
  5. Boasberg found probable cause of criminal contempt; an appeals panel ordered the inquiry ended in April 2026, and the full DC Circuit reheard the case in September 2026. Confirmed

Confirmedbacked by documents or on-record sourcesAllegedclaimed by sources, not provenDisputedcontested by the parties involved

On the evening of 15 March 2025, while Chief Judge James Boasberg was holding an emergency hearing in Washington, the US government flew 252 Venezuelan men out of the country, according to his later ruling 1. Of these, 137 were being removed under the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 12. The planes went to El Salvador, where the men were held in the Terrorism Confinement Center, known as CECOT 1.

The legal basis was a proclamation signed by President Donald Trump and dated 14 March, which declared that the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua (TdA) “is perpetrating, attempting, and threatening an invasion or predatory incursion” against the United States 34. It applied to Venezuelan citizens aged 14 or over who were TdA members and not naturalised citizens or lawful permanent residents, and said the gang had “infiltrated” the government of Nicolás Maduro 3.

Twenty months later, the men are no longer in El Salvador, a federal judge has ruled that they were denied due process, and the questions of whether they can return and whether anyone defied a court order remain before the appeals courts 15.

The night of the flights

Lawyers filed suit at 1:12 a.m. on 15 March after some detainees in Texas contacted them 1. Boasberg blocked the removal of the five named plaintiffs that morning and scheduled a hearing for 5pm 1. The proclamation was made public about an hour before it began 1.

During the hearing, after being told that planes were already in the air, Boasberg verbally ordered that they be turned around 6. They were not, and the instruction did not appear in his written order 6. That evening he certified a class and barred the removal of its members for 14 days 12. The government nonetheless disembarked the men in El Salvador, his December 2025 opinion says 1.

Nayib Bukele, El Salvador’s president, posted on X: “Oopsie…Too late.” Secretary of State Marco Rubio wrote that the US had sent “over 250 alien enemy members of Tren de Aragua” to be held in El Salvador’s “very good jails” 6.

The Associated Press reported that the US had agreed to pay El Salvador $6 million to house about 300 people for a year 67. A US grant letter cited by Boasberg shows $4.7 million transferred for Salvadoran law enforcement needs “which include costs associated with detaining” the men 1. El Salvador’s foreign ministry wrote that it would house them “for one (1) year, pending further decisions on their long-term disposition” 1.

Who was sent

When the men landed, the administration had not named them or given evidence that they belonged to TdA or had committed crimes in the US, AP reported 6.

ProPublica and the Texas Tribune, working with the Venezuelan outlets Alianza Rebelde Investiga and Cazadores de Fake News, examined 238 men sent to CECOT on 15 March 8. Government data showed that 32 had been convicted of crimes in the US, six of them for violent offences, and that 130 were labelled solely as immigration violators 8. Reporters found arrests or convictions abroad for 20 men 8. None of the 238 names matched about 1,400 names on Venezuelan and Interpol gang lists 8. Court filings showed that officials relied partly on tattoos and social media 8.

Human Rights Watch (HRW) and the Salvadoran group Cristosal later concluded that about half of the Venezuelans sent to CECOT had no criminal history, and that 3% had been convicted in the US of a violent or potentially violent offence 9.

The government’s claim about Venezuela’s role was also contested within the US government 10. A National Intelligence Council memo dated 7 April 2025, released under freedom-of-information law, concluded that “the Maduro regime probably does not have a policy of cooperating with TDA” 10. The Office of the Director of National Intelligence later said it “fully supports the assessment” that the gang acts with the regime’s support 10.

The Supreme Court steps in

On 7 April 2025 the Supreme Court voted 5-4 to vacate Boasberg’s orders 112. It held that challenges under the Act must be brought as habeas corpus petitions in the district where detainees are held, not in Washington 112. But it said: “AEA detainees must receive notice after the date of this order that they are subject to removal under the Act.” That notice had to come in time for them to “actually seek habeas relief” 11.

When the government moved to remove more Venezuelans from northern Texas, the court intervened at about 1am on 19 April with an order barring their removal 122. On 16 May it ruled that “notice roughly 24 hours before removal, devoid of information about how to exercise due process rights to contest that removal, surely does not pass muster” 12. It left the government free to remove people “under other lawful authorities” 124.

How it unfolded

  1. Key moment. Trump signs proclamation invoking the Alien Enemies Act against Tren de Aragua.

  2. Key moment. Boasberg blocks removals; planes carry Venezuelan men to CECOT.

  3. Supreme Court vacates Boasberg’s orders but requires notice and habeas.

  4. Boasberg finds probable cause of criminal contempt.

  5. Supreme Court rules 24 hours’ notice inadequate.

  6. ProPublica analysis: 32 of 238 men had US convictions.

  7. Key moment. 252 Venezuelans sent from CECOT to Venezuela in exchange for ten Americans.

  8. HRW and Cristosal report alleges torture at CECOT.

  9. Key moment. Boasberg rules the 137 men were denied due process.

  10. Boasberg orders the government to let men who choose to return do so.

  11. Appeals panel orders the contempt inquiry ended, 2-1.

  12. Fifth Circuit dismisses Texas challenge without ruling on the proclamation.

  13. Key moment. Full DC Circuit hears argument on the contempt inquiry.

Four months in CECOT

HRW and Cristosal interviewed 40 Venezuelans held at CECOT and 150 relatives, lawyers and acquaintances between March and September 2025 9. They allege that guards and riot police beat detainees regularly, including during cell searches, for requesting medical care and after a visit by the International Committee of the Red Cross in May 9. They also report sexual violence against three detainees and scarce food and health care 9.

The groups say many of the abuses amount to torture under international law, and that the detentions were enforced disappearances because both governments refused to disclose where the men were 9. Cristosal helped families file 76 habeas petitions with El Salvador’s Supreme Court, which did not rule on them 9. “The Trump administration is complicit in torture, enforced disappearance, and other grave violations,” said Juanita Goebertus, HRW’s Americas director 9.

In July 2025 Salvadoran officials told the UN human rights office that “the jurisdiction and legal responsibility for these persons lie exclusively with the competent foreign authorities” 7. The US administration had argued in court that the men were beyond the reach of US courts 7.

The exchange

On 18 July 2025 El Salvador sent 252 Venezuelans held at CECOT to Venezuela 13. In return, Venezuela freed ten Americans and released people described as political prisoners 13. “Every wrongfully detained American in Venezuela is now free and back in our homeland,” Rubio said 13. Senior US officials said those returned were “members of the gang Tren de Aragua”; some families denied that their relatives had gang ties 13. Many of the men were reported to be free in Venezuela afterwards, according to their lawyers at the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) 2.

Due process, a year late

On 22 December 2025 Boasberg ruled that the US had kept “constructive custody” of the men in CECOT, giving his court jurisdiction 1. He certified a class of those removed on 15 March and concluded “that this class was denied their due-process rights” 1. He ordered the government to return them or give them hearings that met due-process standards 14.

In January 2026 the government replied that “the situation on the ground in Venezuela is in flux”, a response the ACLU said offered no meaningful remedy 2. On 12 February Boasberg ordered the government to let any of the men who chose to return for immigration proceedings do so, at government expense for those in third countries 15. Anyone who returned would be detained 15.

The contempt fight

On 16 April 2025 Boasberg found probable cause that the government had committed criminal contempt, writing that its actions “demonstrate a willful disregard for its Order” and that “The Constitution does not tolerate willful disobedience of judicial orders” 16. A probable-cause finding is a step towards possible prosecution, not a conviction 16.

The inquiry has gone back and forth on appeal. A DC Circuit panel vacated the finding 2-1 in August 2025. In November the full court declined to rehear the case, but six of its eleven judges wrote that the inquiry was appropriate, and Boasberg resumed it 217. In December the government filed declarations from officials including Kristi Noem, Todd Blanche and Emil Bove 2. It said Ms Noem, then homeland security secretary, had decided that the planes should continue 17.

A former Justice Department lawyer, Erez Reuveni, alleged in a whistleblower disclosure that Mr Bove had told colleagues on 14 March that “the planes needed to take off no matter what”, and that the department might have to tell courts “f— you” 18. Mr Blanche called the claims “utterly false” 18. Mr Bove has since become a federal appeals judge 5.

On 14 April 2026 a panel ruled 2-1 that the inquiry was “a clear abuse of discretion” and ordered it ended 17. Judge Neomi Rao wrote for the majority, joined by Judge Justin Walker; Judge Michelle Childs dissented 175. The full DC Circuit reheard the case on 29 September 2026. “The separation of powers is going to run two ways here,” Judge Patricia Millett told the government’s lawyer 5.

Where it stands

The full DC Circuit reserved its decision on the contempt inquiry after the 29 September 2026 hearing 5. The week before, a separate three-judge panel had expressed doubt that Boasberg could order the men returned to the US 5.

On 13 August 2026 the full Fifth Circuit dismissed a challenge brought by detainees in Texas for lack of jurisdiction after the government removed all three named petitioners under ordinary immigration law 4. An earlier panel ruling in the petitioners’ favour had been vacated when the court agreed to rehear the case 4.

Why it matters

The Supreme Court’s rulings in the case have dealt with procedure, on notice and venue, rather than with whether a gang can be treated as an invading power under a 1798 wartime law 1112; the full Fifth Circuit dismissed its case without deciding that question 4. In the meantime, men whom the government labelled TdA members spent four months in a foreign prison without a hearing, while independent analyses found that a minority had US convictions 891. Whether anyone is held responsible for the flights that left during Boasberg’s hearing is still before the appeals court 5.

The documents

Responses

The White House and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) have defended the removals 814. DHS’s Tricia McLaughlin said the men were “terrorists, human rights abusers, gang members and more — they just don’t have a rap sheet in the U.S.”, and White House spokeswoman Abigail Jackson said “ProPublica should be embarrassed that they are doing the bidding of criminal illegal aliens who are a threat” 8. After the December 2025 ruling Ms McLaughlin said: “Judge Boasberg is way over his skis” 14. The government said it had complied with the law and argued that Boasberg’s oral instructions were defective 16. Todd Blanche, then deputy attorney general, called the whistleblower’s claims “utterly false” 18. El Salvador’s government told the UN that legal responsibility for the men lay “exclusively with the competent foreign authorities” 7. HRW says neither the US nor the Salvadoran government responded to its requests for information 9. Triple Frontiers did not contact those named. Their positions come from statements and court records.

How we reported this

This investigation draws on court opinions from the Supreme Court, the federal court in Washington and the Fifth Circuit, the White House proclamation, and reporting by AP, ABC, CBS, NBC and Courthouse News 311145. Figures on criminal histories come from the ProPublica-led analysis and the HRW-Cristosal report, and are attributed to them 89. Counts of men sent differ between sources (252 in Boasberg’s opinion, 238 in ProPublica’s analysis) and both are given 81. Abuse allegations are those of HRW and Cristosal and are not findings of any court 9. The ACLU, whose case page we cite for procedural dates, represents the plaintiffs 2. We do not name individual deportees. We excluded claims we saw in search results but could not open, including details of a 25 September 2026 appeals hearing 5. We left out reports on any stay of the return order.

Sources and references

  1. Court documentUS District Court for the District of Columbia (hosted by Courthouse News), “J.G.G. v. Trump, Memorandum Opinion (ECF 215)”, 22 December 2025. Link
  2. Official documentACLU of the District of Columbia (counsel for plaintiffs), “J.G.G. v. Trump case page”, 30 January 2026. Link
  3. Official documentThe White House, “Invocation of the Alien Enemies Act Regarding the Invasion of the United States by Tren de Aragua”, 15 March 2025. Link
  4. Court documentUS Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, “W.M.M. v. Trump, No. 25-10534 (en banc)”, 13 August 2026. Link
  5. ArticleCourthouse News Service, “Full DC Circuit grills DOJ in bid to block contempt probe over El Salvador deportations”, 29 September 2026. Link
  6. ArticleAssociated Press (via Fortune), “Trump administration deports hundreds as judge orders their removals be stopped with planes already in the air”, 16 March 2025. Link
  7. ArticleAssociated Press (via ClickOnDetroit), “Migrants deported from US to Salvadoran prison remain under US control, Salvadoran officials tell UN”, 7 July 2025. Link
  8. ReportProPublica / Texas Tribune / Alianza Rebelde Investiga / Cazadores de Fake News, “Trump Administration Knew Vast Majority of Venezuelans Sent to Salvadoran Prison Had Not Been Convicted of U.S. Crimes”, 30 May 2025. Link
  9. ReportHuman Rights Watch, “US/El Salvador: Torture of Venezuelan Deportees”, 12 November 2025. Link
  10. ArticleNBC News, “U.S. intelligence agencies contradict Trump’s Tren de Aragua claims”, 6 May 2025. Link
  11. Court documentSupreme Court of the United States, “Trump v. J.G.G., No. 24A931”, 7 April 2025. Link
  12. Court documentSupreme Court of the United States, “A.A.R.P. v. Trump, No. 24A1007”, 16 May 2025. Link
  13. ArticleCBS News, “10 Americans freed in prisoner swap between U.S., El Salvador and Venezuela”, 18 July 2025. Link
  14. ArticleCBS News, “Judge orders Trump administration to file plan to return Venezuelans sent to El Salvador prison to U.S. or give them hearings”, 23 December 2025. Link
  15. ArticleNBC News, “Judge orders return of Venezuelans formerly detained in El Salvador if they choose to come back”, 12 February 2026. Link
  16. ArticleABC News (via 6abc), “Administration likely acted in contempt by not returning deportation flights: Judge”, 16 April 2025. Link
  17. ArticleCBS News, “Appeals court shuts down criminal contempt probe over deportation flights of Venezuelan migrants”, 14 April 2026. Link
  18. ArticleNBC News, “Whistleblower says top DOJ official suggested ignoring court orders on deportations”, 24 June 2025. Link

Sources and references are provided for transparency and further reading. Allegations and claims are attributed to their respective sources. Triple Frontiers distinguishes reported allegations from independently established facts.

Spotted an error? Request a correction · Corrections policy

Corrections and updates

No corrections have been made to this article.

Share this story

The Alien Enemies Act flights: how Venezuelans were sent to El Salvador’s CECOT

Newsroom desk Investigations Desk

Long-form accountability reporting built on documents and records. Stories are researched from official records, court documents, institutional reports and published journalism, with the help of AI research tools, and edited for Triple Frontiers. Every factual claim is linked to its source.

Newsletter

The Frontier Brief

The week’s essential international reporting and new investigations, every Friday.