Butler and West Palm Beach: the 2024 attempts on Trump’s life and what followed
A gunman wounded Donald Trump at a Pennsylvania rally in July 2024; two months later an agent fired at an armed man at his Florida golf course. Reviews found the Butler failures preventable, and Ryan Routh is appealing a life sentence.

WASHINGTON Donald Trump was wounded on 13 July 2024 when a gunman fired eight shots at him from a rooftop during a campaign rally at the Butler Farm Show grounds in Butler, Pennsylvania, according to the Department of Homeland Security’s inspector general 1. One spectator was killed and others were wounded 1. Two months later, on 15 September 2024, a Secret Service agent at Trump’s golf course in West Palm Beach, Florida, fired at a man pointing a rifle from the fence line 2.
The Butler gunman was killed at the scene 34. The Florida suspect, Ryan Wesley Routh, was convicted on all five counts in September 2025 and sentenced to life in prison plus seven years in February 2026 2. He has appealed 5.
Butler: the shooting
Thomas Crooks climbed onto the roof of a building in the American Glass Research (AGR) complex, next to the rally site, and opened fire at about 6:11 p.m., the inspector general found 1. The complex lay outside the security perimeter drawn by the Secret Service agents planning the event 16. The inspector general put the distance from the roof to the stage at 155 yards 1. Trump said the upper part of his right ear was pierced 3.
The FBI identified the gunman as Thomas Matthew Crooks, 20, of Bethel Park, Pennsylvania 3. A Secret Service sniper killed him 4. An AR-style rifle was recovered, and investigators believed it had been bought by his father, the Associated Press reported 3.
Pennsylvania State Police named the man killed as Corey Comperatore, 50, of Sarver 7. Comperatore was a former fire chief 4. David Dutch, 57, of New Kensington, and James Copenhaver, 74, of Moon Township, were wounded and listed in stable condition 7. “These victims and their families are certainly in our thoughts today,” said the state police commissioner, Col. Christopher Paris 7.
Investigations into the Secret Service
The Washington Post described the shooting as the first attack on a US leader under Secret Service protection in more than 40 years 8. The director of the Secret Service, Kimberly Cheatle, resigned on 23 July 2024, a day after testifying to the House Oversight Committee 8. In a letter to staff she said she took “full responsibility” 8.
On 20 September 2024 the agency released findings of its internal review, acknowledging that it had relied too heavily on local police to secure nearby buildings and that agencies had used separate radio frequencies 9. “It’s important that we hold ourselves to account for the failures of July 13,” said the acting director, Ronald Rowe 9.
An independent review panel reported on 17 October 2024 that “the Secret Service as an agency requires fundamental reform to carry out its mission” 10. “Without that reform, the Independent Review Panel believes another Butler can and will happen again,” it wrote 10. A House task force led by Representative Mike Kelly released a 180-page final report in December 2024 that called Butler “preventable” and made 36 recommendations 611.
In July 2025 the Secret Service suspended six employees without pay for between 10 and 42 days 124. A Senate Homeland Security committee report released on 13 July 2025 by its chairman, Rand Paul, described “a cascade of preventable failures” 13. It said an agent in a security room learned of a suspicious person with a rangefinder about 25 minutes before the shooting, but the warning did not reach Trump’s detail in time 4. “Despite those failures, no one has been fired,” Paul said 13. The Secret Service director, Sean Curran, said the agency had “implemented substantive reforms” 413.
In November 2025 the FBI director, Kash Patel, said an investigation involving more than 480 FBI employees found that Crooks “planned and conducted the attack alone” 14. The FBI has not publicly identified a motive 14.
How it unfolded
-
Key moment. Crooks fires eight shots at Trump from the AGR roof in Butler; Corey Comperatore killed {p20}{p1}
-
Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle resigns {p3}
-
Key moment. Agent fires at Routh at Trump International Golf Club; Routh arrested on I-95 {p15}
-
Routh indicted on attempted assassination charge {p5}
-
Independent panel calls for ‘fundamental reform’ {p6}
-
House task force final report: 36 recommendations {p7}
-
Six Secret Service employees suspended; Senate report published {p9}{p10}
-
Key moment. Jury convicts Routh on all five counts {p13}
-
Key moment. Routh sentenced to life plus seven years {p15}
-
Notice of appeal filed to the Eleventh Circuit {p18}
-
DHS inspector general report on Butler failures {p20}
West Palm Beach: arrest and charges
On 15 September 2024, Robert Fercano, then a Secret Service special agent, was patrolling one hole ahead of Trump at Trump International Golf Club when he saw Routh pointing a rifle at him from a hide in the fence line, the Justice Department said 2. Fercano fired, and Routh fled 2. Authorities say Routh did not fire his weapon 15. Officers arrested him on Interstate 95 after a witness reported seeing him get into a black Nissan Xterra 2.
Prosecutors alleged that phone records showed Routh had waited outside the fence line for nearly 12 hours 15. On 24 September 2024 a grand jury indicted him on charges including attempting to assassinate a major presidential candidate and assaulting a federal officer, adding to earlier gun charges 1516. “Violence targeting public officials endangers everything our country stands for,” said the then attorney general, Merrick Garland 15. In April 2025 Florida’s attorney general, James Uthmeier, announced separate state charges of attempted first-degree murder and terrorism 1718.
Trial, verdict and sentence
Routh waived his right to a lawyer in July 2025 and represented himself at trial in Fort Pierce, Florida 1619. Evidence included a scoped Norinco SKS rifle, steel armour plates, a camera aimed at the sixth green and a handwritten letter addressed “Dear World” 2. In it he wrote: “This was an assassination attempt on Donald Trump but I am so sorry I failed you” 2.
In his closing argument Routh did little to dispute the facts, arguing that “the opportunity was there, and the trigger was not pulled” 19. The judge told jurors that abandoning a plan is not a defence 19. On 23 September 2025 the jury convicted him on all five counts 16. Moments after the verdict he tried to harm himself with a pen and was restrained by deputy marshals 16. His daughter shouted: “he didn’t hurt anybody. This isn’t fair” 19.
US District Judge Aileen Cannon later granted his request for a lawyer for sentencing 16. The defence asked for about 27 years; prosecutors asked for life 20. On 4 February 2026 Cannon sentenced Routh to life plus 84 months 2. “Your plot to kill was deliberate and evil,” she told him 21. “Routh will never walk free again,” said the attorney general, Pamela Bondi 2.
Where things stand
On 13 February 2026 Routh’s lawyer, Martin L. Roth, filed a notice of appeal to the US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit 5. The appeal challenges both the conviction and the sentence 22. Roth has said the judge was wrong to apply a federal terrorism sentencing enhancement 21.
A report by the DHS Office of Inspector General dated 30 June 2026 found that the Secret Service missed several chances to stop Crooks 1. Its staff failed to detect a drone he flew over the site for about nine minutes that afternoon, did not receive 102 radio transmissions from local police about the search for him, and did not block the line of sight from the AGR roof 1. The Secret Service accepted all seven recommendations; four remained open when the report was issued 1.
In a separate case, on 17 November 2026 a federal judge in Brooklyn sentenced Asif Merchant, a Pakistani national, to 330 months in prison for a 2024 plot that prosecutors said was directed by Iran’s Revolutionary Guards to assassinate US politicians; the Justice Department said Merchant believed the ultimate target was Trump 23. Merchant, who was arrested in July 2024, a day before the Butler shooting, plans to appeal; the AP reported that his case was unrelated to Butler 24.
Why it matters
Internal, independent, congressional and inspector-general reviews of Butler all identified failures by the Secret Service 91061, and the House task force and Senate committee called them preventable 613. The Routh case produced a life sentence for attempting to kill a major presidential candidate, and his appeal to the Eleventh Circuit will decide whether the conviction and sentence stand 25.
Sources and references
- Official documentDHS Office of Inspector General, “The Secret Service Missed Opportunities to Prevent and Disrupt the Attempted Assassination of President Trump on July 13, 2024 (OIG-26-13, redacted)”, 30 June 2026. Link
- Official documentUS Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs, “Ryan Wesley Routh Sentenced to Life in Prison for Attempted Assassination of President Donald J. Trump and Assault of a Federal Law Enforcement Officer”, 4 February 2026. Link
- ArticlePBS NewsHour / Associated Press, “The FBI named a suspect in the Trump assassination attempt. Here’s what we know”, 14 July 2024. Link
- ArticleNPR (via WFAE), “Senate committee details failures by Secret Service in preventing Trump shooting”, 13 July 2025. Link
- Court documentUS District Court, Southern District of Florida, “United States v. Routh, Case No. 24-CR-80116-AMC, Notice of Appeal (ECF No. 400)”, 13 February 2026. Link
- ArticleNBC News, “House task force releases final report on Trump assassination attempts”, 10 December 2024. Link
- Official documentPennsylvania State Police, “Pennsylvania State Police Identify Victims Shot During Attempted Assassination of Former President Trump”, 14 July 2024. Link
- ArticleThe Spokesman-Review / The Washington Post, “Secret Service Director Cheatle resigns in aftermath of Trump rally shooting”, 23 July 2024. Link
- ArticleNPR (via WFAE), “The Secret Service admits failures in Butler, Pa., Trump shooting”, 20 September 2024. Link
- ArticlePBS NewsHour / Associated Press, “Secret Service needs ‘fundamental reform,’ panel examining Trump assassination attempt says”, 17 October 2024. Link
- Official documentUS Government Publishing Office, “House Report 118-873: Final Report of the Task Force on the Attempted Assassination of Donald J. Trump (cover page)”, 12 December 2024. Link
- ArticlePolitico (via Yahoo News), “Secret Service suspends 6 agents over handling of Butler shooting”, 11 July 2025. Link
- ArticleRoll Call, “Senate panel faults Secret Service over Trump shooting attempt”, 14 July 2025. Link
- ArticleFox News, “Trump rally gunman acted alone, FBI says, as questions about motive persist”, 18 November 2025. Link
- ArticleNPR (via WFAE), “Ryan Routh is charged with attempted assassination of former President Donald Trump”, 24 September 2024. Link
- Court documentUS District Court, Southern District of Florida, “United States v. Routh, No. 24-80116-CR-CANNON, Order granting in part motion to revoke pro se status and continuing sentencing (ECF No. 364)”, 10 November 2025. Link
- ArticleWLRN / Associated Press, “Florida brings charges against a man jailed on federal counts of trying to assassinate Trump”, 10 April 2025. Link
- ArticleWPTV, “Florida is charging Ryan Routh for attempted assassination of Donald Trump, AG says”, 10 April 2025. Link
- ArticleNPR (via WFAE), “Ryan Routh found guilty on all charges in attempted assassination of Donald Trump”, 24 September 2025. Link
- ArticlePBS NewsHour / Associated Press, “Man gets life in prison for trying to assassinate Trump at a Florida golf course”, 4 February 2026. Link
- ArticleNPR (via WBHM), “Ryan Routh, convicted of trying to assassinate Trump, sentenced to life in prison”, 4 February 2026. Link
- ArticleWEAR-TV (Sinclair), “Appeal filed: Man convicted in Trump golf club assassination plot challenges life term”, 16 February 2026. Link
- Official documentUS Department of Justice, “Iranian intelligence agent sentenced to over 27 years in prison”, 17 November 2026. Link
- ArticleNBC News (AP), “Pakistani man sentenced to 27 years over assassination plot”, 17 November 2026. Link
Sources and references are provided for transparency and further reading. Allegations and claims are attributed to their respective sources. Triple Frontiers distinguishes reported allegations from independently established facts.
The Frontier Brief
The week’s essential international reporting and new investigations, every Friday.



