Triple Frontiers
Retrospective · Courts

Lucy Letby: refused appeals, a disputed expert panel and the Thirlwall report

Lucy Letby's convictions for murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others stand after two refused appeals. A CCRC review of disputed medical evidence is under way, prosecutors have ruled out further charges, and the Thirlwall Inquiry has found a 'complete failure' to protect babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital.

RetrospectiveEvents of 15 September 2026. Published by Triple Frontiers on 18 November 2026 as part of our archive covering events before our launch, based on the sources listed below.
Signposted pedestrian entrance to the Countess of Chester Hospital
Pedestrian entrance to the Countess of Chester Hospital, Chester (file photo, 2005)Photo: Dennis Turner / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)

On 15 September 2026, the public inquiry into the Countess of Chester Hospital found there had been “a complete failure to protect babies” on its neonatal unit, where the former nurse Lucy Letby worked 1. The report, by Lady Justice Thirlwall, said some collapses and deaths could have been avoided had safeguarding practices been followed 12.

Letby is serving 15 whole-life orders for murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others between June 2015 and June 2016 34. She maintains her innocence 24. Her convictions stand: the Court of Appeal has twice refused her permission to appeal, and a review by the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), the body that can send cases back to that court, is under way 5672.

Two refused appeals

Three Court of Appeal judges, led by Dame Victoria Sharp, heard Letby’s renewed application in April 2024 and announced on 24 May 2024 that it was refused 6. Their written reasons followed on 2 July 2024 6.

The judges rejected every ground. These included a challenge to the evidence of the prosecution’s expert, Dr Dewi Evans, whom the court found suitably qualified 6. They also declined to admit fresh evidence in the form of two reports on air embolus by Dr Shoo Lee, a retired neonatologist 6. “We do not consider that the criteria for the admission of fresh evidence have been met,” the judgment said 6.

On 24 October 2024 a second panel refused permission to challenge Letby’s July 2024 conviction, at a retrial, for the attempted murder of another baby 7. Her lawyers had argued that the charge should have been stayed because of media coverage of her first trial 7.

The expert panel and the CCRC

Letby’s lawyers lodged a preliminary application with the CCRC on 3 February 2025 5. The next day, at a news conference in London, a panel of 14 international experts led by Dr Lee presented its review of the medical records of 17 babies 8.

“In summary, then, ladies and gentlemen, we did not find any murders,” Dr Lee said 8. The panel attributed each death or collapse to natural causes or poor medical care, and said the hospital had inadequate staffing 8. Letby’s barrister, Mark McDonald, said the medical evidence put to the jury “has been demolished” 8.

Dr Evans had described concerns about his evidence as “unsubstantiated, unfounded, inaccurate” 8. The Crown Prosecution Service did not comment on the panel’s findings; it had previously pointed out that two juries convicted Letby and that three appeal judges rejected arguments that the prosecution’s expert evidence was flawed 8.

Families of the babies, through their lawyers, opposed bids by Letby’s team and former hospital executives in March 2025 to pause the inquiry 9. Richard Baker KC, for one group of families, called the bid “an attempt to control the narrative” 9. Peter Skelton, for a second group, said the new evidence “turns out to be old and full of analytical holes” 9.

The CCRC’s published timeline shows main submissions arriving in May 2025, then further expert reports through 2025 and into January 2026 5. On 13 February 2026 the commission said: “A review of Ms Letby’s convictions is underway” 5. It added: “It is not for the CCRC to determine innocence or guilt in a case; that’s a matter for the courts” 5. It gave no timescale 5. PA reported that campaigners had submitted 31 reports by 26 experts 3.

On 14 September 2026 two defence experts, Helen Shannon and Geoff Chase, left the team 10. In a letter to the CCRC, they said some arguments being put forward could not be supported “as scientifically credible” 10. They stood by their own view that it was “very unlikely” that two babies had been poisoned with insulin 10. McDonald disagreed that the case had been undermined. “Both sets of experts say that Lucy Letby is innocent,” he said 10.

How it unfolded

  1. Key moment. Court of Appeal refuses Letby leave to appeal her 2023 convictions; reasons follow on 2 July.

  2. Court of Appeal refuses permission to challenge her retrial conviction.

  3. Key moment. Preliminary application lodged with the CCRC.

  4. Key moment. Expert panel led by Dr Shoo Lee says it found no murders.

  5. Operation Duet widened to gross negligence manslaughter.

  6. Key moment. Three former senior leaders arrested on suspicion of gross negligence manslaughter and bailed.

  7. Key moment. CPS rules out further charges against Letby.

  8. CCRC confirms its review is under way.

  9. Arrest on suspicion of perverting the course of justice.

  10. CPS review upholds no-charge decision.

  11. Two experts leave Letby’s defence team.

  12. Key moment. Thirlwall Inquiry report published.

Police investigations and charging decisions

Cheshire Constabulary sent prosecutors a file in July 2025 on further allegations against Letby 11. On 20 January 2026 the CPS said it would bring no further charges 113. It had considered 11 charges concerning nine babies at the Countess of Chester and Liverpool Women’s hospitals, and found the evidential test was not met in any of them 11.

The force said the decision was “not the outcome that we had anticipated throughout our investigation” and that it believed its evidence met the charging standard 3. After families sought a review concerning six infants, a prosecutor independent of the original decision upheld it; on 5 August 2026 the CPS described that outcome as final 12.

A separate police inquiry, Operation Duet, began in October 2023 as a corporate manslaughter investigation into the hospital’s leadership and was widened in March 2025 to include gross negligence manslaughter 13. On 30 June 2025 police arrested three people who were in the hospital’s senior leadership team in 2015-16, on suspicion of gross negligence manslaughter; they were released on bail 13. Police said the investigation “does not impact on the convictions of Lucy Letby” 13.

On 22 April 2026 officers executed a search warrant and arrested a person on suspicion of perverting the course of justice, who was then bailed 14. Arrest is not a charge, and those arrested are presumed innocent 1314.

The Thirlwall report

The report, published in three volumes with a summary, did not review Letby’s convictions 152. Instead it examined how the hospital responded 2.

It described “dysfunctional management and governance” and a gulf between hospital leaders and clinicians 1. Doctors who raised concerns were investigated through Letby’s grievance process, and three consultants were told to apologise to her 1. Letby was moved to administrative duties in July 2016, but police were not invited to investigate until May 2017, and she was arrested in July 2018 24. PA reported the finding that three babies’ deaths could have been prevented had police been contacted sooner 4.

The former chief executive, Tony Chambers, denied stalling or obstructing the police; Lady Justice Thirlwall disagreed 2. Parents, she said, “were kept in the dark for years about what was happening” 2.

The inquiry said it made 17 recommendations, including cameras in all neonatal cots and incubators and CCTV on insulin storage 1. The Health Secretary, Yvette Cooper, said she was “profoundly sorry” and asked officials to plan the cot cameras 4.

McDonald rejected the report. “Everything in this inquiry (Thirlwall) is tainted by the fact that they’ve worked on the wrong premise,” he said 4. Irwin Mitchell, which represents seven families, said: “The families deserve more than expressions of regret and promises of change” 16.

Where the case stands

As of the latest reports in September 2026, Letby’s convictions and sentences remain in force, the CCRC was still considering her application, and both strands of Operation Duet were continuing 410. Inquests into the babies’ deaths are due in May 2027 4. The CPS’s no-charge decision on the further allegations is final 12.

Why it matters

Letby’s convictions have survived two appeal attempts, but the CCRC is weighing expert evidence that disputes the medical basis of the prosecution, and the defence experts are themselves now divided 5610. The Thirlwall report and Operation Duet have moved scrutiny to the hospital’s leaders, and the government has begun acting on its neonatal safety recommendations 1314.

Sources and references

  1. Official documentThirlwall Inquiry, “Inquiry Report finds profound failure of management, governance and safeguarding”, 15 September 2026. Link
  2. ArticleAssociated Press via PBS NewsHour, “Judge blasts hospital for failure to protect babies (AP)”, 15 September 2026. Link
  3. ArticleRTÉ, “No further charges against Lucy Letby (PA)”, 20 January 2026. Link
  4. ArticleThe Irish News (PA), “Three babies could have been saved if police called sooner, Letby inquiry finds (PA)”, 15 September 2026. Link
  5. Official documentCriminal Cases Review Commission, “Chair’s statement on Lucy Letby application review”, 13 February 2026. Link
  6. Court documentCourt of Appeal (National Archives), “Letby v R [2024] EWCA Crim 748”, 2 July 2024. Link
  7. ArticleRTÉ, “Lucy Letby loses bid to appeal attempted murder conviction”, 24 October 2024. Link
  8. ArticleAssociated Press via KSAT, “Medical experts dispute evidence used to convict British nurse Lucy Letby of murder (AP)”, 4 February 2025. Link
  9. ArticleThe Irish News (PA), “Lucy Letby ‘continuing to try to control the narrative’, say families of victims (PA)”, 18 March 2025. Link
  10. ArticleThe Irish News (PA), “Lucy Letby’s lawyer insists case has not been undermined after experts quit (PA)”, 15 September 2026. Link
  11. Official documentCrown Prosecution Service, “No criminal charges against Lucy Letby in relation to further allegations”, 20 January 2026. Link
  12. Official documentCrown Prosecution Service, “Decision not to charge Lucy Letby with further offences upheld”, 5 August 2026. Link
  13. ArticleRTÉ (Reuters/PA), “Three arrested in Countess of Chester investigation”, 1 July 2025. Link
  14. ArticleHello Rayo (Bauer Media), “New arrest in Lucy Letby gross negligence manslaughter investigation”, 23 April 2026. Link
  15. Official documentGOV.UK, “Thirlwall Inquiry report”, 15 September 2026. Link
  16. Official documentIrwin Mitchell, “Families affected by Lucy Letby crimes react as Thirlwall Inquiry report published”, 15 September 2026. Link

Sources and references are provided for transparency and further reading. Allegations and claims are attributed to their respective sources. Triple Frontiers distinguishes reported allegations from independently established facts.

Spotted an error? Request a correction · Corrections policy

Share this story

Lucy Letby: refused appeals, a disputed expert panel and the Thirlwall report

Newsroom desk Crime Desk

Criminal justice, organised crime, policing and the courts. Stories are researched from official records, court documents, institutional reports and published journalism, with the help of AI research tools, and edited for Triple Frontiers. Every factual claim is linked to its source.

Newsletter

The Frontier Brief

The week’s essential international reporting and new investigations, every Friday.